It is occasionally required to repeat a procedure. Individual Retirement Arrangement (IRA) and Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) are not the same thing. Though they are both tax-advantaged retirement savings plans, the rules can differ dramatically, and individuals who are unaware of the variations may pay a premium when it comes to filing taxes.
“When one withdraws from the Roth TSP, their withdrawals are viewed as coming first from their contributions,” one reader said on a recent piece about the Roth tax trap. Withdrawals will be considered as coming from their wages and, thus, liable to federal income tax only when they have taken an amount equivalent to their contributions from their Roth balance.” This is not the case. This is true for withdrawals from Roth IRAs, but not for withdrawals from the TSP (or from other employer sponsored retirement plans for that matter). A person who believed the IRA and TSP rules were equivalent and acted on that notion would be in for a rude awakening come tax season.
Is TSP a traditional or Roth IRA?
The biggest distinction between a Roth TSP account and a Roth IRA is the Roth IRA contribution restrictions. Roth IRAs have both contribution and income restrictions. The Roth TSP, on the other hand, has no income limits and is open to any federal employee.
Is TSP an IRA or 401k?
The TSP is a tax-deferred savings plan “For government employees, there is a “employer” retirement plan that is similar to a 401k plan in the private sector. An IRA is a tax-deferred investment account “Individualized” retirement strategy What a change! The TSP must adhere to Section 401k of the Internal Revenue Code’s administrative guidelines.
What is the difference between an IRA and a TSP?
TSP contributions must be made through payroll deduction, but IRA contributions can be made from any source as long as you have enough earned income to match the payment. The TSP does not allow you to contribute from your earned income to a non-working spouse’s IRA.
You can take money out of your IRA in any way you want and at any time. TSP withdrawals are still more restricted than IRA withdrawals, even after the TSP Modernization Act was passed in September.
In an IRA, you have the option of choosing your distribution source, including the individual investment inside the IRA. Withdrawals from the TSP must be made proportionally between funds. Furthermore, unless you designate otherwise, distributions from your TSP are made proportionally between regular and Roth balances. Standard and Roth IRAs are separate accounts, therefore you can’t have both traditional and Roth money in the same IRA.
Individuals are also prohibited from using a TSP because to the proportionality requirement “When making withdrawals, use the “bucket strategy.” The bucket technique, often known as a time-based segmentation approach, is dividing your money between two or more different accounts/funds, or buckets “a bucket”
The first bucket would be invested in safe (but lower-yielding) investments from which you would take monthly income withdrawals in retirement. A second bucket would be placed in higher-risk (but potentially higher-yielding) investments that won’t be needed for a while. Bucket one would be replenished from bucket two on a regular basis. According to Investopedia, 38% of financial counselors recommend the bucket technique to their customers.
Although you can contribute to both the TSP and an IRA, they are not the same. Yes, they are similar; no, they are identical.
What type of IRA is the Thrift Savings Plan?
TSPs and IRAs (conventional and Roth IRAs) are both tax-advantaged retirement funds. The TSP is a type of retirement plan known as a “defined contribution” plan. It’s similar to a 401(k) qualified retirement plan offered by a private employer or a 403(b) qualified retirement plan offered by a non-profit organization. With the decline of traditional defined benefit pension plans during the last quarter-century, defined contribution plan assets have exploded in the last 20 years. As of March 31, 2020, defined contribution plans had $7.9 trillion in assets, according to the Investment Company Institute.
As of March 31, 2020, assets in individual retirement accounts (IRAs) totaled $9.5 trillion. Rollovers and transfers from defined contribution plans, such as the TSP, are included in the $9.5 trillion.
However, defined contribution plans like the TSP and IRAs have their own set of rules and restrictions.
Can I have TSP and IRA?
Yes. Your ability to contribute to an IRA is unaffected by your participation in the TSP. However, the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) has restrictions on how much money you can put into qualifying employment plans like the TSP and individual retirement accounts like regular and Roth IRAs.
Is my TSP a Roth IRA?
It has the potential to make or shatter their retirement. The Thrift Savings Plan, a massive federal-military 401(k) plan, is offering a Roth option for its 4.5 million-plus investors. The TSP, like other 401(k) plans, is a tax-deferred savings vehicle. Until you start taking money from the TSP, it is tax-deferred.
How do I transfer my TSP to an IRA?
3. If you’re going to conduct an indirect rollover, think twice. You tell the TSP to transmit your TSP assets immediately to your new employer’s plan or an IRA, and you never have to touch the money. You seek a lump-sum payout from TSP and then take responsibility for executing the transfer through an indirect rollover. Indirect rollovers have a lot of tax implications. Because the plan is required to withhold 20% to ensure that taxes are paid if the rollover is not completed, you will not receive the whole amount. If you are younger than 591/2, you must deposit the funds in an IRA within 60 days to avoid paying taxes on pretax contributions and gains, as well as the possibility of an additional 10% tax penalty. You must add funds from another source equal to the 20% withheld by the plan administrator if you want to defer taxes on the entire amount you cashed out (you get the 20 percent back if you properly complete the rollover). Learn the difference between direct and indirect rollovers.
4. Be careful of claims of “Free” or “No Fee.” Financial institutions compete fiercely for IRA business, and rollovers and IRA-related services are frequently advertised. Advertising can be deceiving in some circumstances. FINRA has noticed overly broad language in advertisements and other sales materials that implies investors having accounts with the businesses are not charged any fees. There will almost definitely be expenses associated with account administration, investment management, or both, even if there are no costs involved with the rollover itself. Don’t rely on the word “free” to convince you to roll over your retirement assets.
5. Recognize the existence of conflicts of interest. Commissions or other fees may be paid to financial advisors who advocate an IRA rollover. Leaving assets in the TSP or rolling them over to a plan offered by your new employer, on the other hand, is likely to result in little or no income for a financial advisor. In other words, even if the advice is legitimate, any financial professional who advises you to transfer money from your TSP to an IRA stands to gain financially from the move.
6. Evaluate investment and other services choices. An IRA allows you to choose from a wider choice of investment possibilities than an employer plan, but it may not have the same low-cost options as the TSP. The attractiveness of the IRA options will be determined in part by how satisfied you are with the TSP’s possibilities. Investment advice, planning tools, telephone support lines, educational materials, and workshops are all available through some employment plans. IRA providers, therefore, give various levels of service, which may include full brokerage, financial advice, and distribution planning. Consider the tradeoffs if you’re considering a self-directed IRA.
7. Be aware of fees and expenses. Both the TSP and the IRA have investment costs as well as plan or account fees. Sales loads, commissions, expenditures of any mutual funds in which assets are invested, and investment advice fees are all examples of investment-related expenses. Administrative costs (such as recordkeeping and compliance fees) and payments for services, such as access to a customer service agent, can all be included in plan fees. Employers may cover some or all of the plan’s administration costs in some instances. Administrative, account set-up, and custody costs are examples of IRA account fees. Know how much you’re paying TSP to manage your retirement assets before you make a rollover decision. TSP funds have some of the lowest expenditures in the industry. Compare them to the costs and fees associated with a new plan or IRA. Request information on IRA fees and charges from your financial expert, and read your account agreement and any investment prospectuses. Take FINRA’s micro-course on the subject to learn more about why fees and expenses matter and how to control their impact on investments.
8. Have a thoughtful conversation with your financial or tax advisor. Don’t be afraid to bring up topics like tax consequences, service discrepancies, and fees and charges when comparing retirement savings options. If your financial advisor advises you to sell securities in your plan or buy securities in a newly created IRA, inquire as to why the proposal is appropriate for you. Don’t buy it if you don’t understand it, just like any other investment.
9. It is important to consider your age. You may be allowed to take penalty-free withdrawals from the TSP if you leave your work between the ages of 55 and 591/2. In contrast, penalty-free withdrawals from an IRA are normally not permitted until the age of 59 1/2. The rules for both traditional employment plans and traditional IRAs require periodic withdrawals of specific minimum sums, known as required minimum distributions, once you reach age 72 (or 70 1/2 if you reached 70 1/2 before 2020). (RMD). Roth 401(k) accounts are likewise subject to the RMD requirements. However, while the owner is alive, the RMD regulations do not apply to Roth IRAs. You are not required to make necessary minimum distributions from your current employer’s plan if you are still working at age 72. This could be beneficial to people who plan to work well into their 70s.
10. Be aware that you have the option of transferring funds into the TSP rather than out. Many of the ads urging IRA rollovers are geared toward getting money out of TSPs and similar programs. However, you have the option of rolling money in. Transfers and rollovers of tax-deferred money from regular IRAs, SIMPLE IRAs, and qualifying employment plans are all allowed into your standard TSP account. Transfers (or direct rollovers) from an employer-sponsored retirement plan to the TSP are made by the plan participant after receiving a distribution from the plan. The TSP will accept transfers from Roth 401(k), Roth 403(b), and Roth 457(b) accounts into the Roth balance of your TSP account, but you won’t be able to rollover Roth assets into your TSP account indirectly, and you won’t be able to move money from a Roth IRA into your TSP account. The transfer will create a Roth balance in your existing TSP account if you don’t already have one.
Americans’ top financial concern is saving for retirement, and many are unsure of their retirement planning alternatives. The question of whether or not to shift your retirement savings or stay put is a big one. When changing jobs or retiring, you don’t always have to act right away. Take some time to think about your possibilities. To figure out what is best for you, ask questions and do your homework.
Can I have a TSP and Roth IRA?
A: You can contribute to both a Roth IRA and the TSP, but the total amount you can save in both is incorrect; you can actually contribute more. There are, however, annual income limits for Roth IRA contributions.
What is the point of a traditional IRA?
- Traditional IRAs (individual retirement accounts) allow individuals to make pre-tax contributions to a retirement account, which grows tax-deferred until withdrawal during retirement.
- Withdrawals from an IRA are taxed at the current income tax rate of the IRA owner. There are no taxes on capital gains or dividends.
- There are contribution restrictions ($6,000 for those under 50 in 2021 and 2022, 7,000 for those 50 and beyond in 2021 and 2022), and required minimum distributions (RMDs) must commence at age 72.
When can I roll my TSP into an IRA?
A transfer is when the TSP sends money straight from your TSP account to your IRA account. A rollover, on the other hand, is when they personally send you a check, which you must deposit into your IRA within 60 days.
Is TSP a 401k or 403b?
The Thrift Savings Scheme, or TSP, is the federal government’s version of a 401(k), and we’ve produced an explanation of the plan if you want to learn more about it. Is the TSP the same as a 401(k)? They aren’t exactly alike, but they do have a few things in common:
- While the TSP isn’t a 401k, it is a defined contribution plan similar to a 401k (and a 403b for that matter). Defined contribution means that your employer in this example, the federal government will make a certain amount of money toward your retirement, subject to certain conditions.
- Many 401k and 403b programs, like the TSP, offer both regular and Roth options. Contributions to the classic option are tax-deferred and lower your taxable income, but any future withdrawals are taxed. Contributions to the Roth option are not tax deductible, but future withdrawals are not. When it comes to choosing between a standard TSP and a Roth TSP, your financial circumstances will determine which option is best for you. We just published a post that explains the benefits and drawbacks of Roth versus traditional contributions.
- TSP contribution limits are the same as those for 401(k) programs. In 2021, that sum will be $19,500, with a $6,500 catch-up payment for employees 50 and older.
- Your regular and Roth balances can be rolled over into an IRA or a Roth IRA, respectively, once you have separated from the Federal Government and are no longer a Federal employee.
- The Thrift Savings Plan features rules that address both in-service distributions (i.e., withdrawals while still employed) and a TSP loan option, which you can read about here. While we recommend avoiding pulling money out of your retirement accounts whenever possible, if you absolutely must, loans are a considerably more tax-efficient option to do it, assuming the loan is repaid on time.
- TSP and 401k plans both require you to begin taking from the accounts after you reach the age of 72, due to IRS requirements. If you have not yet split from service, you can avoid having to take a mandatory minimum distribution, as these withdrawals are known.
Download Your Free Ultimate Retirement Guide for Federal Employees
The TSP and many 401(k) plans have several key differences. The following are some of them:
- In recent years, there have been two complaints about 401(k) plans: their costs are difficult to estimate for many, and they are often greater than they should be. Administrative fees, as well as fees for investment options, are included in retirement plan fees. TSP account administration fees are cheap, and investment options include a broad range of low-cost index funds. As a result, the TSP is a low-cost plan overall.
- Many 401(k) plans provide a wide range of investing alternatives, and some even provide a “open platform” with hundreds of funds. When it comes to investing, your TSP alternatives are limited, so if you want to invest with a specific manager or fund family, or if you want to pursue a more esoteric approach, you won’t be able to do so through TSP investments. The fact that you can’t invest in emerging economies is perhaps the largest concern with TSP investing possibilities, however this may change in the future. This article provides an overview of investment alternatives as well as portfolio-building advice.
- The federal government contributes 1% of your pay to the TSP automatically, and if you contribute 5% of your salary, they will match up to 4% of your salary. The total match of 5% is more than many 401(k) plans, and when you factor in the FERS payments, the retirement benefits are highly competitive with those in the private sector.
- Once you reached retirement age, you were only allowed one partial withdrawal from the TSP. Many seniors found this to be too restricted, so they elected to roll their TSP into an IRA, from which they could take as much money as they wanted. Fortunately, effective of September 15, 2019, the TSP allows partial withdrawals with more flexibility. We’ve prepared a piece about TSP withdrawal alternatives, including the recently expanded partial withdrawal options, which you can find here.
Overall, the Thrift Savings Plan outperforms 401(k) plans, and if you work for the federal government and are eligible to enroll, you should. It’s a good complement to the FERS pension, and the TSP and FERS together can give a solid retirement basis.
Can I rollover my TSP to an IRA while still employed?
First and foremost, you can contribute to your TSP whether you’re still employed with the federal government or after you’ve left.
- Money from a Traditional employer-sponsored plan, such as a Traditional 401(k), that you had before or during your government job;
- Money from a Traditional IRA, which allows you to deduct your IRA contributions from your federal income tax (also known as a Roth IRA) “IRA with a traditional tax deduction”); and
- The profits component of a Traditional IRA (also known as a Roth IRA) where you have not been able to deduct your IRA contributions from your federal income tax (also known as a Roth IRA) “Non-deductible traditional IRA”).
- Money from a Roth employer-sponsored plan, such as a Roth 401(k), that you had prior to or after working for the federal government.