Bond ETFs can be a great way for investors to diversify their portfolio fast by purchasing just one or two securities. However, investors must consider the drawbacks, such as a high expense ratio, which might eat into returns in this low-interest-rate environment.
Bond ETFs are they a secure investment?
- Market transparency is lacking. Bonds are traded over-the-counter (OTC), which means they are not traded on a single exchange and have no official agreed-upon price. The market is complicated, and investors may find that different brokers offer vastly different prices for the same bond.
- High profit margins. Broker markups on bond prices can be significant, especially for smaller investors; according to one US government research, municipal bond markups can reach 2.5 percent. The cost of investing in individual bonds can quickly pile up due to markups, bid/ask gaps, and the price of the bonds themselves.
- Liquidity issues. Liquidity of bonds varies greatly. Some bonds are traded daily, while others are traded weekly or even monthly, and this is when markets are at their best. During times of market turmoil, some bonds may cease to trade entirely.
A bond ETF is a bond investment in the form of a stock. A bond ETF attempts to replicate the performance of a bond index. Despite the fact that these securities only contain bonds, they trade on an exchange like stocks, giving them some appealing equity-like characteristics.
Bonds and bond ETFs may have the same underlying investments, however bond ETFs’ behavior is affected by exchange trading in numerous ways:
- Bond ETFs do not have a maturity date. Individual bonds have a definite, unchanging maturity date when investors receive their money back; each day invested brings that day closer. Bond ETFs, on the other hand, maintain a constant maturity, which is the weighted average of all the bonds in the portfolio’s maturities. Some of these bonds may be expiring or leaving the age range that a bond ETF is targeting at any given time (e.g., a one- to three-year Treasury bond ETF kicks out all bonds with less than 12 months to maturity). As a result, fresh bonds are regularly purchased and sold in order to maintain the portfolio’s maturity.
- Even in illiquid markets, bond ETFs are liquid. Single bonds have a wide range of tradability. Some issues are traded on a daily basis, while others are only traded once a month. They may not trade at all during times of stress. Bond ETFs, on the other hand, trade on an exchange, which means they can be purchased and sold at any time during market hours, even if the underlying bonds aren’t trading.
This has real-world ramifications. According to one source, high-yield corporate bonds trade on less than half of the days each month, but the iShares iBoxx $ High Yield Corporate Bond ETF (HYG | B-64) trades millions of shares per day.
- Bond ETFs pay a monthly dividend. One of the most appealing features of bonds is that they pay out interest to investors on a regular basis. These coupon payments are usually made every six months. Bond ETFs, on the other hand, hold a variety of issues at once, and some of the bonds in the portfolio may be paying their coupons at any one time. As a result, bond ETFs often pay interest monthly rather than semiannually, and the amount paid can fluctuate from month to month.
- Diversification. You may own hundreds, even thousands, of bonds in an index with an ETF for a fraction of the cost of buying each issue individually. At retail prices, it’s institutional-style diversification.
- Trading convenience. There’s no need to sift through the murky OTC markets to argue over rates. With the click of a button, you may purchase and sell bond ETFs from your regular brokerage account.
- Bond ETFs can be bought and sold at any time during the trading day, even in foreign or smaller markets where individual securities may trade infrequently.
- Transparency in pricing. There’s no need to guess how much your bond ETF is worth because ETF values are published openly on the market and updated every 15 seconds during the trading day.
- More consistent revenue. Instead of six-monthly coupon payments, bond ETFs often pay interest monthly. Monthly payments provide bond ETF holders with a more consistent income stream to spend or reinvest, even if the value varies from month to month.
- There’s no assurance that you’ll get your money back. Bond ETFs never mature, so they can’t provide the same level of security for your initial investment as actual bonds may. To put it another way, there’s no guarantee that you’ll get your money back at some point in the future.
Some ETF providers, however, have recently began creating ETFs with defined maturity dates, which hold each bond until it expires and then disperse the proceeds once all bonds have matured. Under its BulletShares brand, Guggenheim offers 16 investment-grade and high-yield corporate bond target-maturity-date ETFs with maturities ranging from 2017 to 2018; iShares offers six target-maturity-date municipal ETFs. (See “I Love BulletShares ETFs” for more information.)
- If interest rates rise, you may lose money. Rates of interest fluctuate throughout time. Bonds’ value may fall as a result of this, and selling them could result in a loss on your initial investment. Individual bonds allow you to reduce risk by simply holding on to them until they mature, at which point you will be paid their full face value. However, because bond ETFs don’t mature, there’s little you can do to avoid the pain of rising rates.
Individual bonds are out of reach for the majority of investors. Even if it weren’t, bond ETFs provide a level of diversification, liquidity, and price transparency that single bonds can’t match, plus intraday tradability and more regular income payouts. Bond ETFs may come with some added risks, but for the ordinary investor, they’re arguably a better and more accessible option.
Pros of bond ETFs
- A bond ETF distributes the interest it earns on the bonds it owns. As a result, a bond ETF can be an excellent method to build up an income stream without having to worry about individual bonds maturing or being redeemed.
- Dividends paid on a monthly basis. Some of the most popular bond ETFs pay monthly dividends, providing investors with consistent income over a short period of time. This means that investors can use the regular dividends from bond ETFs to create a monthly budget.
- Immediate diversification is required. A bond ETF can provide rapid diversification throughout your entire portfolio as well as inside the bond segment. As a result, if you add a bond ETF to your portfolio, your returns will be more resilient and consistent than if you simply had equities in your portfolio. Diversification reduces risk in most cases.
- Bond exposure that is tailored to your needs. You can have multiple types of bond ETFs in your bond portfolio, such as a short-term bond fund, an intermediate-term bond fund, and a long-term bond fund. When added to a stock-heavy portfolio, each will react differently to fluctuations in interest rates, resulting in a less volatile portfolio. This is advantageous to investors because they may pick and choose which market segments they want to acquire. Do you only want a small portion of intermediate-term investment-grade bonds or a large portion of high-yield bonds? Check and double-check.
- There’s no need to look at individual bonds. Rather than researching a range of individual bonds, investors can choose the types of bonds they want in their portfolio and then “plug and play” with the appropriate ETF. Bond ETFs are also a great option for financial advisers, particularly robo-advisors, who are looking to round out a client’s diverse portfolio with the correct mix of risk and return.
- It’s less expensive than buying bonds directly. Bond markets are generally less liquid than stock markets, with substantially greater bid-ask spreads that cost investors money. By purchasing a bond ETF, you are leveraging the fund company’s capacity to obtain better bond pricing, lowering your own expenses.
- You don’t require as much cash. If you want to buy a bond ETF, you’ll have to pay the price of a share (or even less if you choose a broker that permits fractional shares). And that’s a lot better than the customary $1,000 minimum for buying a single bond.
- Bond ETFs also make bond investment more accessible to individual investors, which is a fantastic feature. In comparison to the stock market, the bond market can be opaque and lack liquidity. Bond ETFs, on the other hand, are traded on the stock exchange like stocks and allow investors to quickly enter and exit positions. Although it may not appear so, liquidity may be the single most important benefit of a bond ETF for individual investors.
- Tax-efficiency. The ETF structure is tax-efficient, with minimal, if any, capital gains passed on to investors.
Cons of bond ETFs
- Expense ratios could be quite high. If there’s one flaw with bond ETFs, it’s their expense ratios the fees that investors pay to the fund management to administer the fund. Because interest rates are so low, a bond fund’s expenses may eat up a significant percentage of the money provided by its holdings, turning a small yield into a negligible one.
- Returns are low. Another potential disadvantage of bond ETFs has less to do with the ETFs themselves and more to do with interest rates. Rates are expected to remain low for some time, particularly for shorter-term bonds, and the situation will be aggravated by bond expense ratios. If you buy a bond ETF, the bonds are normally chosen by passively mirroring an index, thus the yields will most likely represent the larger market. An actively managed mutual fund, on the other hand, may provide some extra juice, but you’ll almost certainly have to pay a higher cost ratio to get into it. However, in terms of higher returns, the higher cost may be justified.
- There are no promises about the principal. There are no assurances on your principal while investing in the stock market. If interest rates rise against you, the wrong bond fund might lose a lot of money. Long-term funds, for example, will be harmed more than short-term funds as interest rates rise. If you have to sell a bond ETF while it is down, no one will compensate you for the loss. As a result, for some savers, a CD may be a preferable option because the FDIC guarantees the principal up to a limit of $250,000 per person, per account type, at each bank.
Is it worthwhile to invest in bonds?
- Bonds are a generally safe investment, which is one of its advantages. Bond prices do not move nearly as much as stock prices.
- Another advantage of bonds is that they provide a consistent income stream by paying you a defined sum of interest twice a year.
- You may assist enhance a local school system, establish a hospital, or develop a public garden by purchasing a municipal bond.
- Diversification One of the most important advantages of bond investment is the diversification it provides to your portfolio. Stocks have outperformed bonds throughout time, but having a mix of both lowers your financial risk.
Which bond ETF is the safest?
Many investors’ portfolios include money market exchange-traded funds (ETFs) because they provide safety and capital preservation in a volatile market. These funds often invest in high-quality, highly liquid short-term debt instruments such as U.S. Treasury bonds and commercial paper, which don’t typically provide much income.
While the majority of money market ETFs’ assets are invested in cash equivalents or highly rated securities with extremely short maturities, some may invest a part of their assets in longer-term or lower-graded securities. Investors should be aware that these securities have more risks.
Despite the fact that all investments come with some risk, the following money market ETFs are a relatively safe choice for investors:
Continue reading to learn more about these investments. The data presented here is current as of May 11, 2021.
Is it possible to lose all of my money in ETFs?
While there are many wonderful new ETFs on the market, anything promising a free lunch should be avoided. Examine the marketing materials carefully, make an effort to thoroughly comprehend the underlying index’s strategy, and be skeptical of any backtested returns.
The amount of money invested in an ETF should be inversely proportionate to the amount of press it receives, according to the rule of thumb. That new ETF for Social Media, 3-D Printing, and Machine Learning? It isn’t appropriate for the majority of your portfolio.
8) Risk of Overcrowding in the Market
The “hot new thing risk” is linked to the “packed trade risk.” Frequently, ETFs will uncover hidden gems in the financial markets, such as investments that provide significant value to investors. A good example is bank loans. Most investors had never heard of bank loans until a few years ago; today, bank-loan ETFs are worth more than $10 billion.
That’s fantastic… but keep in mind that as money pours in, an asset’s appeal may dwindle. Furthermore, some of these new asset types have liquidity restrictions. Valuations may be affected if money rushes out.
That’s not to say that bank loans, emerging market debt, low-volatility techniques, or anything else should be avoided. Just keep in mind while you’re buying: if this asset wasn’t fundamental to your portfolio a year ago, it should still be on the periphery today.
9) The Risk of Trading ETFs
You can’t always buy an ETF with no transaction expenses, unlike mutual funds. An ETF, like any other stock, has a spread that can range from a penny to hundreds of dollars. Spreads can also change over time, being narrow one day and broad the next. Worse, an ETF’s liquidity can be superficial: the ETF may trade one penny wide for the first 100 shares, but you may have to pay a quarter spread to sell 10,000 shares rapidly.
Trading fees can drastically deplete your profits. Before you buy an ETF, learn about its liquidity and always trade with limit orders.
10) The Risk of a Broken ETF
ETFs, for the most part, do exactly what they’re designed to do: they happily track their indexes and trade close to their net asset value. However, if something in the ETF fails, prices can spiral out of control.
It’s not always the ETF’s fault. The Egyptian Stock Exchange was shut down for several weeks during the Arab Spring. The only diversified, publicly traded option to guess on where the Egyptian market would open after things calmed down was through the Market Vectors Egypt ETF (EGPT | F-57). Western investors were very positive during the closure, bidding the ETF up considerably from where the market was prior to the revolution. When Egypt reopened, however, the market was essentially flat, and the ETF’s value plunged. Investors were burned, but it wasn’t the ETF’s responsibility.
We’ve seen this happen with ETNs and commodity ETFs when the product has stopped issuing new shares for various reasons. These funds can trade at huge premiums, and if you acquire one at a significant premium, you should expect to lose money when you sell it.
ETFs, on the whole, do what they say they’re going to do, and they do it well. However, to claim that there are no dangers is to deny reality. Make sure you finish your homework.
Bond ETFs retain bonds until they mature.
Bond ETFs provide many of the same characteristics as actual bonds, such as a consistent coupon payment. One of the most important advantages of bond ownership is the ability to receive fixed payments on a regular basis. Traditionally, these payments are made every six months. Bond ETFs, on the other hand, own assets with varying maturities. As a result, some bonds in the portfolio may be due for a coupon payment at any given time. As a result, bond ETFs pay interest every month, with the coupon value fluctuating from month to month.
The fund’s assets are constantly changing and do not mature. Instead, bonds are purchased and sold as they approach or leave the fund’s designated age range. Despite the absence of liquidity in the bond market, the difficulty for the architect of a bond ETF is to guarantee that it closely matches its appropriate index in a cost-effective manner. Because most bonds are held until they mature, there is usually no active secondary market for them. This makes ensuring that a bond ETF has enough liquid bonds to mirror an index difficult. Corporate bonds face a greater challenge than government obligations.
Bond ETF providers get around the liquidity issue by utilizing representative sampling, which basically means tracking a small enough number of bonds to form an index. The representative sample bonds are often the largest and most liquid in the index. Tracking mistakes will be less of a concern with ETFs that represent government bond indices due to the liquidity of government bonds.
Bond ETFs are a terrific way to get exposure to the bond market, but they have a few drawbacks. For one reason, in an ETF, an investor’s initial investment is at greater risk than in a single bond. Because a bond ETF never matures, there is no certainty that the principal will be fully repaid. Furthermore, when interest rates rise, the ETF’s price, like the price of an individual bond, tends to fall. However, because the ETF does not mature, it is difficult to manage interest rate risk.
When is the best time to buy a bond?
It’s better to buy bonds when interest rates are high and peaking if your goal is to improve overall return and “you have some flexibility in either how much you invest or when you may invest.” “Rising interest rates can potentially be a tailwind” for long-term bond fund investors, according to Barrickman.
In 2021, how will bonds perform?
Corporate bonds performed well in the first half of 2021, with high yield bonds leading the way. The price decreases linked to rising Treasury rates were cushioned by demand for yield and a stronger credit quality outlook. Despite this, investment-grade corporate bonds had negative total returns in the first half of the year, while lower-credit-quality high-yield bonds had positive total returns.