They lose because they are net monetary creditors. However, they benefit as demand deposit issuers. The second effect may easily outweigh the first with more indexing and more accurate forecasting of future inflation.
Bankers have recently learned to recognize and manage interest rate risk. Bankers learned of the need to hedge their balance sheets against this risk by applying duration analysis, thanks in large part to the efforts of the editor of this journal in a series of articles in American Banker. The duration of equity (a value-weighted average of the durations of assets and liabilities) was set to zero to protect the bank from interest rate risk. With this position, the bank was considered to be immune to modest changes in interest rates. However, this immunization technique only safeguarded the bank’s nominal market value, not its real market value that is, the bank’s market value in today’s dollars, not the bank’s market value in inflation-adjusted dollars. This post aims to start a conversation on how to correct this oversight.
Do banks profit or lose money as a result of inflation? Is it the rate of inflation or the rate of change that matters? Is the impact of pricing changes symmetric? Is it true that disinflation has the same but opposite effects as inflation? What role do expectations play in the process? Is it possible for banks to avoid these consequences?
We’re mostly interested in the impact of shifting prices on net interest income and capital values here. The impact of inflation on noninterest revenue and expenses, as well as the real resource production function of banks, will be discussed in future articles. This latter assumption equates to the plausible (but controversial) belief that actual (inflation-adjusted) noninterest revenue and expense are unrelated to price changes for the purposes of this article.
The focus is on how inflation affects banks, rather than how banks have been affected by specific inflations. As a result, we exclude factors such as increased bank competition and regulatory changes (both of which have a significant impact on bank earnings), as these are not always caused by inflation.
We start by going over the economic literature and the basic “overview” ideas. We then show how both theories are subsets of a broader approach whose major components are rates of change in expectations and portfolio adjustment speeds. The more comprehensive hypothesis serves as a foundation for future research.
In the economics and finance literature, the impact of inflation on actual bank earnings has been extensively explored. There are two competing and opposing models. Banks, according to Alchian and Kessel (A-K), are net monetary creditors (i.e., their nominal assets are greater than nominal liabilities). As a result, rising prices would reduce the value of their nominal assets more than their nominal liabilities. As a result, banks will lose money during an inflationary period.
The inflation tax school, on the other hand, argues that because banks’ demand deposits account for a component of the money supply, they should be able to capture a piece of the inflation tax and so profit during an inflation….
What impact does inflation have on banks?
- Inflation is defined as an increase in the price of goods and services that results in a decrease in the buying power of money.
- Depending on the conditions, inflation might benefit both borrowers and lenders.
- Prices can be directly affected by the money supply; prices may rise as the money supply rises, assuming no change in economic activity.
- Borrowers gain from inflation because they may repay lenders with money that is worth less than it was when they borrowed it.
- When prices rise as a result of inflation, demand for borrowing rises, resulting in higher interest rates, which benefit lenders.
Do banks handle inflation well?
Inflation in the United States continues to rise, with the price index for American consumer spending (PCE index), the Fed’s preferred measure of inflation, rising at a rate of 4.2 percent in the year ended July, its highest level in over 30 years. Furthermore, core prices rose 3.6 percent, excluding volatile goods like food and energy. The figures come as a result of rising demand for products and services, which has outpaced supply systems’ ability to keep up following the Covid-19 lockdowns. Although the Fed is optimistic that inflation will fall, noting that it would likely lower its $120 billion in monthly asset purchases this year, the figure is still significantly above the Fed’s target of 2% inflation.
However, we believe that inflation will continue to be slightly higher than historical levels for some years. Personal savings, for example, have increased as a result of the epidemic, and the continuance of low interest rates over the next two years could result in higher prices for goods and services. Companies in the banking, insurance, consumer staples, and energy sectors are among the companies in our Inflation Stocks category that could stay steady or even benefit from high inflation. Compared to the S&P 500, which is up roughly 18% year to date, the theme has returned around 15%. Exxon Mobil has been the best performer in our topic, with a year-to-date gain of 28 percent. Chubb’s stock has also performed well this year, with a gain of roughly 20% thus far. Procter & Gamble, on the other hand, has been the worst performer, with its stock climbing only roughly 4% year to date.
Inflation in the United States surged to its highest level since 2008 in June, as the economy continues to recover from the Covid-19-related lockdowns. According to the Labor Department, the consumer price index increased by 5.4 percent year over year, while the core price index, which excludes food and energy, increased by 4.5 percent. Prices have risen as a result of increased demand for products and services, which has outpaced enterprises’ ability to meet it. Although supply-side bottlenecks should be resolved in the coming quarters, variables such as large stimulus spending, a jump in the US personal savings rate, and a continuance of the low-interest rate environment over the next two years could suggest inflation will remain high in the near future.
So, how should equities investors respond to the current inflationary climate? Companies in the banking, insurance, consumer staples, and energy sectors are among the companies in our Inflation Stocks category that could stay steady or even benefit from high inflation. Year-to-date, the theme has returned nearly 16%, roughly in line with the S&P 500. It has, however, underperformed since the end of 2019, remaining about flat in comparison to the S&P 500, which is up around 35%. Exxon Mobil, the world’s largest oil and gas company, has been the best performer in our topic, with a year-to-date gain of about 43%. Procter & Gamble, on the other hand, has underperformed, with its price holding approximately flat.
Inflation in the United States has been rising as a result of plentiful liquidity, skyrocketing demand following the Covid-19 lockdowns, and supply-side limitations. The Federal Reserve increased its inflation projections for 2021 on Wednesday, forecasting a 3.4 percent increase in personal consumption expenditures – its preferred inflation gauge – this year, a full percentage point more than its March projection of 2.4 percent. The central bank made no adjustments to its ambitious bond-buying program and said interest rates will remain near zero percent through 2023, while signaling two rate hikes.
So, how should stock investors respond to the current inflationary climate and the possibility of increased interest rates? Stocks in the banking, insurance, consumer staples, and energy sectors might stay constant or possibly gain from increasing inflation rates, according to our Inflation Stocks theme. The theme has outpaced the market, with a year-to-date return of almost 17% vs just over 13% for the S&P 500. It has, however, underperformed since the end of 2019, remaining about flat in comparison to the S&P 500, which is up almost 31%. Exxon Mobil, the world’s largest oil and gas company, has been the best performer in our subject, climbing 56 percent year to far. Procter & Gamble, on the other hand, has lagged the market this year, with its shares down approximately 5%.
Inflation has been rising, owing to central banks’ expansionary monetary policies, pent-up demand for commodities following the Coivd-19 lockdowns, company inventory replenishment or build-up, and significant supply-side constraints. Now it appears that inflation is here to stay, with the 10-Year Breakeven Inflation rate, which represents predicted inflation rates over the next ten years, hovering around 2.4 percent, its highest level since 2013.
So, how should equities investors respond to the current inflationary climate? Stocks To Play Rising Inflation is a subject that contains stocks that could stay stable or possibly gain from higher inflation rates. The theme has outpaced the market, with a year-to-date return of almost 18% vs just over 12% for the S&P 500. However, it has underperformed since the end of 2019, returning only roughly 1% compared to 30% for the S&P 500. The theme consists primarily of stocks in the banking, insurance, consumer staples, and energy sectors, all of which are expected to gain from greater inflation in the long run. Metals, building materials, and electronics manufacturing have been eliminated because they performed exceptionally well during the initial reopening but appear to be nearing their peak. Here is a bit more about the stocks and sectors in our topic.
Banking Stocks: Banks profit from the net interest spread, which is the difference between the interest rates on deposits and the interest rates on loans they make. Higher inflation now often leads to higher interest rates, which can help banks increase their net interest revenue and earnings. Banks, on the other hand, will benefit from increased credit card spending by customers. Citigroup and U.S. Bank are two banks in our subject that have a stronger exposure to retail banking. Citigroup’s stock is up 26% year to date, while U.S. Bancorp is up 28%.
Insurance stocks: Underwriting surplus cash is often invested to create interest revenue by insurance companies. Inflationary pressures, which result in increased interest rates, can now aid boost their profits. Companies like The Travelers Companies and Chubb, which rely on investment income more than their peers in the insurance industry, should benefit. This year, Travelers stock has increased by around 12%, while Chubb has increased by 8%.
Consumer staples: Consumer equities should also hold up well in the face of increasing inflation. Because these enterprises deal with critical products, demand remains consistent, and they can pass on greater costs to customers. Our theme includes tobacco behemoth Altria Group, which is up 21% this year, food and beverage behemoth PepsiCo, which is almost flat, and consumer goods behemoth Procter & Gamble, which is down around 1%.
Oil and Gas: During periods of rising consumer prices, energy equities have performed admirably. While growing economies are good for oil demand and pricing, huge oil corporations have a lot of operating leverage, which allows them to make more money as revenue climbs. Exxon Mobil, which has gained a stunning 43 percent this year, and Chevron, which has risen roughly 23 percent, are two of our theme’s picks.
Heavy equipment manufacturers, electrical systems suppliers, automation solutions providers, and semiconductor fabrication equipment players are among the companies in our Capex Cycle Stocks category that stand to benefit from increased capital investment by businesses and the government.
What if you’d rather have a more well-balanced portfolio? Since the end of 2016, this high-quality portfolio has regularly outperformed the market.
Why are banks so opposed to inflation?
When the rate of inflation differs from expectations, the amount of interest repaid or earned differs from what they expected. Unexpected inflation hurts lenders since the money they are paid back has less purchasing power than the money they lent out.
Is inflation beneficial or harmful?
- Inflation, according to economists, occurs when the supply of money exceeds the demand for it.
- When inflation helps to raise consumer demand and consumption, which drives economic growth, it is considered as a positive.
- Some people believe inflation is necessary to prevent deflation, while others say it is a drag on the economy.
- Some inflation, according to John Maynard Keynes, helps to avoid the Paradox of Thrift, or postponed consumption.
Is bank stock affected by inflation?
Consumers, stocks, and the economy may all suffer as a result of rising inflation. When inflation is high, value stocks perform better, and when inflation is low, growth stocks perform better. When inflation is high, stocks become more volatile.
Do banks fare well during a downturn?
First, during a recession, interest rates tend to fall. Because banks’ principal business model is to lend money and profit, lower interest rates tend to result in reduced earnings. For instance, if a bank’s average vehicle loan interest rate is 5%, it will make significantly more money than if the average rate is 3%, all other circumstances being equal.
Second, and more importantly, during recessions, unemployment tends to rise, and more consumers get into financial difficulty. Consumers sometimes have difficulties paying their bills during recessions, which can result in an increase in loan losses for banks.
The longer answer, though, is that each bank is unique. Consumer banking (accepting deposits and lending money) is very cyclical, particularly for banks that specialize in riskier forms of lending like credit cards. Investment banking, on the other hand, performs even better during stormy times, therefore banks with strong investment banking businesses typically see profits hold up well. Goldman Sachs, for example.
What is creating 2021 inflation?
As fractured supply chains combined with increased consumer demand for secondhand vehicles and construction materials, 2021 saw the fastest annual price rise since the early 1980s.
Inflation benefits who?
Inflation Benefits Whom? While inflation provides minimal benefit to consumers, it can provide a boost to investors who hold assets in inflation-affected countries. If energy costs rise, for example, investors who own stock in energy businesses may see their stock values climb as well.
Why is inflation so detrimental to investors?
Most individuals are aware that inflation raises the cost of their food and depreciates the worth of their money. In reality, inflation impacts every aspect of the economy, and it can eat into your investment returns over time.
What is inflation?
Inflation is the gradual increase in the average cost of goods and services. The Bureau of Labor Statistics, which compiles data to construct the Consumer Price Index, measures it (CPI). The CPI measures the general rise in the price of consumer goods and services by tracking the cost of products such as fuel, food, clothing, and automobiles over time.
The cost of living, as measured by the CPI, increased by 7% in 2021.
1 This translates to a 7% year-over-year increase in prices. This means that a car that costs $20,000 in 2020 will cost $21,400 in 2021.
Inflation is heavily influenced by supply and demand. When demand for a good or service increases, and supply for that same good or service decreases, prices tend to rise. Many factors influence supply and demand on a national and worldwide level, including the cost of commodities and labor, income and goods taxes, and loan availability.
According to Rob Haworth, investment strategy director at U.S. Bank, “we’re currently seeing challenges in the supply chain of various items as a result of pandemic-related economic shutdowns.” This has resulted in pricing imbalances and increased prices. For example, due to a lack of microchips, the supply of new cars has decreased dramatically during the last year. As a result, demand for old cars is increasing. Both new and used car prices have risen as a result of these reasons.
Read a more in-depth study of the present economic environment’s impact on inflation from U.S. Bank investment strategists.
Indicators of rising inflation
There are three factors that can cause inflation, which is commonly referred to as reflation.
- Monetary policies of the Federal Reserve (Fed), including interest rates. The Fed has pledged to maintain interest rates low for the time being. This may encourage low-cost borrowing, resulting in increased economic activity and demand for goods and services.
- Oil prices, in particular, have been rising. Oil demand is intimately linked to economic activity because it is required for the production and transportation of goods. Oil prices have climbed in recent months, owing to increased economic activity and demand, as well as tighter supply. Future oil price rises are anticipated to be moderated as producer supply recovers to meet expanding demand.
- Reduced reliance on imported goods and services is known as regionalization. The pursuit of the lowest-cost manufacturer has been the driving force behind the outsourcing of manufacturing during the last decade. As companies return to the United States, the cost of manufacturing, including commodities and labor, is expected to rise, resulting in inflation.
Future results will be influenced by the economic recovery and rising inflation across asset classes. Investors should think about how it might affect their investment strategies, says Haworth.
How can inflation affect investments?
When inflation rises, assets with fixed, long-term cash flows perform poorly because the purchasing value of those future cash payments decreases over time. Commodities and assets with changeable cash flows, such as property rental income, on the other hand, tend to fare better as inflation rises.
Even if you put your money in a savings account with a low interest rate, inflation can eat away at your savings.
In theory, your earnings should stay up with inflation while you’re working. Inflation reduces your purchasing power when you’re living off your savings, such as in retirement. In order to ensure that you have enough assets to endure throughout your retirement years, you must consider inflation into your retirement funds.
Fixed income instruments, such as bonds, treasuries, and CDs, are typically purchased by investors who want a steady stream of income in the form of interest payments. However, because most fixed income assets have the same interest rate until maturity, the buying power of interest payments decreases as inflation rises. As a result, as inflation rises, bond prices tend to fall.
The fact that most bonds pay fixed interest, or coupon payments, is one explanation. Inflation reduces the present value of a bond’s future fixed cash payments by eroding the buying power of its future (fixed) coupon income. Accelerating inflation is considerably more damaging to longer-term bonds, due to the cumulative effect of decreasing buying power for future cash flows.
Riskier high yield bonds often produce greater earnings, and hence have a larger buffer than their investment grade equivalents when inflation rises, says Haworth.
Stocks have outperformed inflation over the previous 30 years, according to a study conducted by the US Bank Asset Management Group.
2 Revenues and earnings should, in theory, increase at the same rate as inflation. This means your stock’s price should rise in lockstep with consumer and producer goods prices.
In the past 30 years, when inflation has accelerated, U.S. stocks have tended to climb in price, though the association has not been very strong.
Larger corporations have a stronger association with inflation than mid-sized corporations, while mid-sized corporations have a stronger relationship with inflation than smaller corporations. When inflation rose, foreign stocks in developed nations tended to fall in value, while developing market stocks had an even larger negative link.
In somewhat rising inflation conditions, larger U.S. corporate equities may bring some benefit, says Haworth. However, in more robust inflation settings, they are not the most successful investment tool.
According to a study conducted by the US Bank Asset Management Group, real assets such as commodities and real estate have a positive link with inflation.
Commodities have shown to be a dependable approach to hedge against rising inflation in the past. Inflation is calculated by following the prices of goods and services that frequently contain commodities, as well as products that are closely tied to commodities. Oil and other energy-related commodities have a particularly strong link to inflation (see above). When inflation accelerates, industrial and precious metals prices tend to rise as well.
Commodities, on the other hand, have significant disadvantages, argues Haworth. They are more volatile than other asset types, provide no income, and have historically underperformed stocks and bonds over longer periods of time.
As it comes to real estate, when the price of products and services rises, property owners can typically increase rent payments, which can lead to increased profits and investor payouts.
Is inflation beneficial to homeowners?
For homeowners: Inflation is a positive thing for property owners for a variety of reasons. The most obvious advantage is that your home’s value rises in tandem with inflation.