- When inflation is high, value stocks perform better, and when inflation is low, growth stocks perform better.
Do growth or value equities perform better in an inflationary environment?
It seems strange to be concerned about inflation during one of the sharpest and most severe economic downturns in our lifetimes.
However, given the Federal Reserve’s massive government spending and monetary policy, it’s something that many are thinking about as a potential risk in the not-too-distant future. The “concern” is that once the virus has been contained, the economy could overheat as a result of pent-up demand and government spending.
My initial take on this is that if we do get inflation as a result of all of this spending, it’s a good thing since it implies we’ve beaten the virus and are back to business as usual (if there is such a thing).
I’m not taking a victory lap here because I certainly didn’t expect inflation to reach nearly 8%. I hadn’t anticipated so many supply chain challenges as a result of high consumer demand.
And that piece wasn’t so much about making a macro call as it was about figuring out why value equities had fallen so far behind growth stocks in the years preceding up to the epidemic.
My conclusion was that more inflation was required for value stocks to outperform once more. Here’s how it looks:
Value has tended to do better during decades with above-average inflation and worse during decades with lower inflation, however this is not a perfect link. This was my original theory for why this happened:
Consider growth stocks in the same way that you would a bond. The purchasing value of your fixed rate income payments is reduced over time by inflation, which is why inflation is such a huge risk for bondholders.
The same can be said for growth stocks’ predicted future revenue or profit growth. Value stocks are likely to have cash flows that are already decreasing and will continue to do so in the future. As a result, higher interest rates should affect value equities less than growth companies, because the higher hurdle rate reduces the value of future growth.
Let’s put this notion to the test now that inflation has been rising for almost a year.
Since the beginning of 2021 through Monday’s closing, the DFA small and large cap value funds1 have outperformed the market and growth stocks:
During this inflationary period, value equities have excelled by a wide margin. So far, everything has gone well.
When inflation is greater, value tends to outperform for international companies as well:
It would be naive to believe that inflation is the only driver driving value or growth equities. Inflation has a part, but nominal growth is typically higher when inflation is high.
And sometimes value outperforms growth because growth values are too far off the mark.
Because I can’t forecast the future path of inflation (and I’m not sure anyone else can either), I’m not smart enough to predict whether value stocks will continue to thrive.
However, this serves as an excellent reminder of the significance of diversifying your portfolio across economic cycles.
Since reading Ray Dalio’s The All Weather Story a few years ago, this chart from the book has stayed with me:
Because we don’t know when or why the economic environment will change, the aim is to combine investments that work under different economic regimes together.
No one predicted a major inflation/economic growth increase in 2019, yet that’s exactly what we’re experiencing right now.
In a long time, we haven’t had to deal with a rising inflation/increasing growth economy.
Value stocks have been behind for some time, but perhaps they just needed the ideal circumstances to shine.
I’m not predicting that value investment will continue to outperform. I honestly have no idea.
I’m not sure how much of the inflation story has already been priced into value and growth equities.
I’m not sure if the Fed will be able to keep inflation under control.
I am aware that building a long-term portfolio necessitates diversity of techniques that may thrive in a variety of market and economic conditions.
1Full disclosure: DFA funds are used in several of my firm’s client portfolios, and I own some of these funds.
Why are growth stocks affected by inflation?
Inflationary pressures, on the other hand, might be problematic for growth stocks. Because higher interest rates and bond yields are expected as a result of inflation, growth stocks’ promised future cash flows become less appealing.
What should you buy in advance of inflation?
With food prices, there are a few simple strategies to prepare for inflation. I believe it is prudent to begin preparing now and purchasing items before you require them. This is what I’ve been concentrating on recently. In its most basic form, a stockpile is just that.
Assume the price of toilet paper increases by 15% this year. That means the $10 toilet paper package you buy every month will soon be $11.50. That’s an extra $18 each year merely to buy the same toilet paper you were buying before. If you multiply that scenario by a number of things increasing in price, you’ll see a significant influence on your budget.
What if there isn’t any inflation? You’ll still be prepared and won’t have to purchase some of these products for a while. Because costs aren’t going down, you won’t lose anything. They may or may not increase at the greater rates predicted by some. If the hyperinflation predictions come true, you will have saved money for your family by purchasing items ahead of time while we wait for inflation to return to more normal levels.
“Buy one now, and two later,” as the old adage goes. Never let yourself get to the end of your food supplies.
Always be on the lookout and purchasing ahead of time. When you come across a good offer, buy as much as you can, especially non-perishables.
Personally, we are relocating funds from other sections of our budget in order to focus on purchasing some additional items right now. You should think about doing the same.
Are you trying to figure out what to buy before inflation? Here are a few essentials to stock up on before inflation kicks in.
Build a stockpile of non-perishable goods.
This is one of the most effective methods for anticipating inflation. Now is the time to stock up on items that will not expire or spoil. When I uncover good prices, I usually focus on establishing a food stockpile. Right now, I’m concentrating on accumulating a non-perishable food supply.
Build a stockpile of things you use regularly.
Expand your stockpile in the same way as before, focusing on the items your family utilizes on a regular basis. Don’t think about eating just yet. Concentrate on toiletries and other items that you use. Don’t buy goods you won’t utilize because it’s a waste of money. Consider stocking up on these items before inflation sets in.
Build a stockpile of foods your family eats.
The perishable products that your family consumes on a regular basis are the last section of your stockpile that you should concentrate on.
Purchase extras of the food items you use whenever you notice a good offer. If you have extra freezer space, concentrate on buying meat when you can get a good deal.
When it comes to canned goods and other packaged goods, buy only what you’ll use before they expire.
If you’re wondering what food to stockpile before inflation rises even further, consider the following:
Can you save a few dollars this week to purchase an extra roll of toilet paper? Or can you find some additional cash to buy a few extra diaper packages? Is it possible to buy four containers of dish soap instead of one? Keep in mind that anything you purchase now will assist you in planning for the future.
I just produced a printable PDF called “The Quick Start Guide to Building a Stockpile on a Budget” if you want to learn more about stockpiling. It’s jam-packed with useful hints, checklists, and more to help you create a stockpile even as inflation rises! More information can be found here.
Are stocks a good way to protect against inflation?
You might not think of a house as a smart method to protect yourself against inflation, but if you buy it with a mortgage, it can be a great way to do so. With a long-term mortgage, you may lock in affordable financing for up to three decades at near-historically low rates.
A fixed-rate mortgage allows you to keep the majority of your housing costs in one payment. Property taxes will increase, and other costs will climb, but your monthly housing payment will remain the same. If you’re renting, that’s definitely not the case.
And, of course, owning a home entails the possibility of its value rising over time. Price appreciation is possible if additional money enters the market.
Stocks
Stocks are a solid long-term inflation hedge, even though they may be battered by nervous investors in the near term as their concerns grow. However, not all stocks are equivalent in terms of inflation protection. You’ll want to seek for organizations with pricing power, which means they can raise prices on their clients as their own costs grow.
And if a company’s profits increase over time, so should its stock price. While inflation fears may affect the stock market, the top companies are able to weather the storm thanks to their superior economics.
Gold
When inflation rises or interest rates are extremely low, gold has traditionally been a safe-haven asset for investors. When real interest rates that is, the reported rate of interest minus the inflation rate go below zero, gold tends to do well. During difficult economic times, investors often look to gold as a store of value, and it has served this purpose for a long time.
One effective way to invest in gold is to acquire it through an exchange-traded fund (ETF). This way, you won’t have to own and protect the gold yourself. Plus, ETFs provide you the option of owning actual gold or equities of gold miners, which can provide a bigger return if gold prices rise.
What happens to the stock market in a hyperinflationary environment?
Inflationary periods, such as those seen in the United States in the late 1970s and early 1980s, are generally not considered beneficial economic times, as prices often rise faster than salaries. Hyperinflation is considerably worse because it is accompanied by a sharp increase in prices. The most well-known instance of hyperinflation occurred in Germany shortly after World War II, when a loaf of bread was said to require a wheelbarrow full of paper money. Stock prices, like all other prices, will soar under hyperinflation.
Is inflation beneficial to investors?
Most individuals are aware that inflation raises the cost of their food and depreciates the worth of their money. In reality, inflation impacts every aspect of the economy, and it can eat into your investment returns over time.
What is inflation?
Inflation is the gradual increase in the average cost of goods and services. The Bureau of Labor Statistics, which compiles data to construct the Consumer Price Index, measures it (CPI). The CPI measures the general rise in the price of consumer goods and services by tracking the cost of products such as fuel, food, clothing, and automobiles over time.
The cost of living, as measured by the CPI, increased by 7% in 2021.
1 This translates to a 7% year-over-year increase in prices. This means that a car that costs $20,000 in 2020 will cost $21,400 in 2021.
Inflation is heavily influenced by supply and demand. When demand for a good or service increases, and supply for that same good or service decreases, prices tend to rise. Many factors influence supply and demand on a national and worldwide level, including the cost of commodities and labor, income and goods taxes, and loan availability.
According to Rob Haworth, investment strategy director at U.S. Bank, “we’re currently seeing challenges in the supply chain of various items as a result of pandemic-related economic shutdowns.” This has resulted in pricing imbalances and increased prices. For example, due to a lack of microchips, the supply of new cars has decreased dramatically during the last year. As a result, demand for old cars is increasing. Both new and used car prices have risen as a result of these reasons.
Read a more in-depth study of the present economic environment’s impact on inflation from U.S. Bank investment strategists.
Indicators of rising inflation
There are three factors that can cause inflation, which is commonly referred to as reflation.
- Monetary policies of the Federal Reserve (Fed), including interest rates. The Fed has pledged to maintain interest rates low for the time being. This may encourage low-cost borrowing, resulting in increased economic activity and demand for goods and services.
- Oil prices, in particular, have been rising. Oil demand is intimately linked to economic activity because it is required for the production and transportation of goods. Oil prices have climbed in recent months, owing to increased economic activity and demand, as well as tighter supply. Future oil price rises are anticipated to be moderated as producer supply recovers to meet expanding demand.
- Reduced reliance on imported goods and services is known as regionalization. The pursuit of the lowest-cost manufacturer has been the driving force behind the outsourcing of manufacturing during the last decade. As companies return to the United States, the cost of manufacturing, including commodities and labor, is expected to rise, resulting in inflation.
Future results will be influenced by the economic recovery and rising inflation across asset classes. Investors should think about how it might affect their investment strategies, says Haworth.
How can inflation affect investments?
When inflation rises, assets with fixed, long-term cash flows perform poorly because the purchasing value of those future cash payments decreases over time. Commodities and assets with changeable cash flows, such as property rental income, on the other hand, tend to fare better as inflation rises.
Even if you put your money in a savings account with a low interest rate, inflation can eat away at your savings.
In theory, your earnings should stay up with inflation while you’re working. Inflation reduces your purchasing power when you’re living off your savings, such as in retirement. In order to ensure that you have enough assets to endure throughout your retirement years, you must consider inflation into your retirement funds.
Fixed income instruments, such as bonds, treasuries, and CDs, are typically purchased by investors who want a steady stream of income in the form of interest payments. However, because most fixed income assets have the same interest rate until maturity, the buying power of interest payments decreases as inflation rises. As a result, as inflation rises, bond prices tend to fall.
The fact that most bonds pay fixed interest, or coupon payments, is one explanation. Inflation reduces the present value of a bond’s future fixed cash payments by eroding the buying power of its future (fixed) coupon income. Accelerating inflation is considerably more damaging to longer-term bonds, due to the cumulative effect of decreasing buying power for future cash flows.
Riskier high yield bonds often produce greater earnings, and hence have a larger buffer than their investment grade equivalents when inflation rises, says Haworth.
Stocks have outperformed inflation over the previous 30 years, according to a study conducted by the US Bank Asset Management Group.
2 Revenues and earnings should, in theory, increase at the same rate as inflation. This means your stock’s price should rise in lockstep with consumer and producer goods prices.
In the past 30 years, when inflation has accelerated, U.S. stocks have tended to climb in price, though the association has not been very strong.
Larger corporations have a stronger association with inflation than mid-sized corporations, while mid-sized corporations have a stronger relationship with inflation than smaller corporations. When inflation rose, foreign stocks in developed nations tended to fall in value, while developing market stocks had an even larger negative link.
In somewhat rising inflation conditions, larger U.S. corporate equities may bring some benefit, says Haworth. However, in more robust inflation settings, they are not the most successful investment tool.
According to a study conducted by the US Bank Asset Management Group, real assets such as commodities and real estate have a positive link with inflation.
Commodities have shown to be a dependable approach to hedge against rising inflation in the past. Inflation is calculated by following the prices of goods and services that frequently contain commodities, as well as products that are closely tied to commodities. Oil and other energy-related commodities have a particularly strong link to inflation (see above). When inflation accelerates, industrial and precious metals prices tend to rise as well.
Commodities, on the other hand, have significant disadvantages, argues Haworth. They are more volatile than other asset types, provide no income, and have historically underperformed stocks and bonds over longer periods of time.
As it comes to real estate, when the price of products and services rises, property owners can typically increase rent payments, which can lead to increased profits and investor payouts.
When it comes to inflation, why does value exceed growth?
If you invest 100 in a value business with a price/earnings (P/E) ratio of 5x, for example, that multiple means your shares should produce 20 each year in profits, and thus you will’recover’ your investment after five years. A growth company, on the other hand, is likely to have a high P/E ratio, implying low earnings now, but growth investors are willing to pay up in the hopes of generating money in years 16 to 20, rather than the first five.
That makes the value business a’short-duration’ asset and the growth business a ‘long-duration’ asset in financial terms. Regardless of the fancy verbiage, the crucial practical lesson is that money now is worth more than money in the future in an inflationary climate. The more money is invested in the future, the less it is worth. As a result, in an inflationary environment, value, which sees investors repay their money sooner rather than later, is more appealing.
Investors, on the other hand, have been significantly less anxious about inflation than deflation during the last seven years or so. Prices of goods and services typically rise with time (that is, they inflate), thus 1 buys you less and less as you look further into the future.
Deflation, on the other hand, causes prices of goods and services to fall, so your 1 will buy you progressively more things or services the further out you look. In a deflationary economy, growth firms, or those with a long-term solid franchise, are valued much higher than value enterprises.
This is why growth companies, particularly high-quality companies with pricing power so-called ‘bond proxies,’ such as food, beverage, and cigarette companies have performed so well recently. It’s also why, if you feel inflation is on its way back and we don’t have an opinion on that, either way it would reverse a big chunk of value’s recent underperformance.
Inflation favours whom?
- Inflation is defined as an increase in the price of goods and services that results in a decrease in the buying power of money.
- Depending on the conditions, inflation might benefit both borrowers and lenders.
- Prices can be directly affected by the money supply; prices may rise as the money supply rises, assuming no change in economic activity.
- Borrowers gain from inflation because they may repay lenders with money that is worth less than it was when they borrowed it.
- When prices rise as a result of inflation, demand for borrowing rises, resulting in higher interest rates, which benefit lenders.
Is inflation beneficial to technology stocks?
High-growth equities have struggled throughout 2021 and this amazing start to 2022, owing to fears that the Fed may raise interest rates to battle inflation, putting pressure on their valuations. Professor Vittorio de Pedys criticizes all three pillars of the mainstream argument in this contribution based on his impact paper.
The Fed is unquestionably behind the curve when it comes to dealing with inflation. The M2 money supply indicator, which increased by 40% from 2019 to 2021, is a clear indicator of price pressure. Today’s supply chain bottlenecks are the outcome of economic limitations being countered with a significant shift in demand for products vs services, rather than a global economy unraveling. Companies are addressing this issue by re-engineering their supply chains and constructing factories (see Intel, Taiwan semiconductors). The IHS Markit PMI indices in emerging markets have all recently increased considerably, indicating that manufacturing capacity is improving. Money’s velocity is decreasing: because to productivity-enhancing technology, businesses are spending money less fast. Prices will continue to fall as a result of this secular trend. Finally, comparisons will be easier: inflation will be recorded in the second quarter of 2022 versus the substantially higher numbers witnessed throughout 2021. In 2022, tougher comps will inevitably hold down headline inflation. Market data backs up this assertion: the 5×5 years forward-forward in Libor/inflation swaps, a leading indication of market expectations, indicates that market dealers estimate inflation to be 2.5 percent in five years.
Fed funds rates will aim 2.5 percent in 2024 under the most extreme scenario. It’s hardly a frightening figure. Given the high quantity of business and student debt and its low quality, if the Fed hikes rates above the inflation peak, it risks halting the economic growth and unleashing a cascade of bankruptcies, resulting in an economic crisis. The cost of government debt servicing might soar, pushing out other, more vital public spending. On the other hand, if the Fed decides to maintain its current policy, its dovish posture will further fuel inflationary expectations. As a result, the inflate or die trap appears to be the best option. A strong US dollar will also assist in the long run. Because the real rate is minus 5.5 percent, the government can sit back and watch its mountain of debt (now at 136 percent of GDP) shrink. When looking at Fed Funds Future deliveries for the end of 2022 on the CBOT, the market is pricing a 0.874 percent O/N rate one year from now with three rate hikes. A similar message can be found in the EuroDollar Futures, with the expected 3-months rate for June 2024 trading at an unimpressive 1.37 percent. Chairman Jerome Powell is no Paul Volcker, so the Fed will put on a hawkish mask to gain time, then back down as inflation starts to fall in the second half of 2022.
According to Vittorio de Pedys, 2022 will be a stronger year than 2021 since rate hikes are beneficial to hypergrowth stocks. It’s the “roaring technological twenties”!
Since their all-time high in March 2021, high-growth technology stocks have been steadily declining. According to this logic, the higher the interest rate, the higher the discount rate employed in valuation models such as DCF and CAPM, and the lower the value of a growth stock. Higher inflation, on the other hand, has not historically sunk markets. Rates that are higher do. To destroy growth stocks, substantially higher rates than those proposed by the Fed will be required. Even if most people are unhappy, the economy is essentially in good shape. SPACs, Reddit investors, “meme” stocks, cryptocurrencies, and IPOs are all showing signs of froth. In terms of rates, the “danger” zone begins at 5%. According to studies, there has never been a recession with a rate of less than 4%. Over any 19-year period, US stocks have outpaced inflation 100% of the time, according to Goldman Sachs. The market is telling us that the Fed raised rates eight times between 2016 and 2018, and that growth companies prospered throughout that time: just look at Cathie Wood’s flagship ARK Innovation ETF (ARKK), which soared 90 percent during that time. Growth stocks are damaged by the worry of rising interest rates: the pain is limited to the prospect of higher rates. Once this occurs, these stocks benefit because their superior growth potential is correctly valued above a small multiple compression due to slightly higher discount rates. The adoption of technology by a larger number of people is unstoppable. Hypergrowth stocks are at the heart of these factors, and they will gain from a strengthening economy.