Since 1955, an inverted yield curve in US Treasuries has correctly anticipated every recession, with only one false signal.
How many times has a recession been anticipated by an inverted yield curve?
An inverted yield curve is said to be a sign of impending recession. “The yield curve has reversed 28 times since 1900,” according to Gaggar, “and in 22 of these incidents, a recession has followed.”
Is the yield curve a reliable indicator of economic downturns?
All of the rhetoric about charts and yields is difficult to swallow, but a yield curve inversion is seen to be a solid prediction of a recession.
Is a downward-sloping yield curve a sign of impending recession?
“On the surface, a downward-sloping yield curve just indicates that investors expect rate decreases but does not explain why.” Investors may be concerned about a recession and anticipate a rate cut from the Federal Reserve. Alternatively, they could be anticipating a rate drop by the Fed in reaction to lower inflation.
Why does an inverted yield curve signal a downturn?
The yield curve is one of the most important predictors of economic downturns. This usually refers to the market for borrowing money from the US government by issuing bonds and other securities with maturities ranging from weeks to 30 years.
Each of these securities has its own yield (or interest rate), which varies in inverse proportion to the security’s market value – for example, when bonds trade at high prices, their yields are low, and vice versa. The yield curve is a chart that depicts the yields of securities at each maturity date in order to see how they relate to one another.
In normal times, investors demand greater rates of return for money they lend over a longer time horizon as a compensation for higher risk. The yield curve usually slopes upward to reflect this. When it slopes down, or inverts, it indicates that investors are more pessimistic about the long future than the near term: they believe a downturn or recession is imminent.
This is because they believe the Federal Reserve, the United States’ central bank, will decrease short-term interest rates in the future to help the economy recover (as opposed to raising rates to cool down an economy that is overheating).
The link between two-year and ten-year US Treasury debt is the most closely observed. The graphic below shows the so-called spread between these two indicators, with the grey areas representing recessions that have tended to follow shortly after.
As you can see, the yields on these two securities are approaching parity, and the trend indicates that the two-year will soon have a greater yield, indicating that the curve is inverting. The big question is whether an inverted yield curve signals an impending downturn. Certainly not. Please allow me to explain why.
What if the central bank used Operation Twist to reverse the inverted yield curve, which is a sign of impending recession?
Central banks can sell long-term bonds and buy short-term bonds, increasing long-term bond yields while decreasing short-term bond yields. In this approach, the inverted yield curve can be transformed into a normal-looking ascending slope, masking the true recession indicator.
How long after the yield curve inverts does a recession occur?
Inversions aren’t a precise way to set your watch. According to Gaggar, the average lag between a yield curve inversion and the commencement of a recession has been around 22 months since 1900.
When the yield curve inverts, what does it mean?
For the first time since 2019, 2-year Treasury yields have surpassed 10-year Treasury yields.
This is uncommon since investors usually expect a higher reward for taking on the risk that rising inflation will reduce the expected yield on longer-term bonds. As a result, a 10-year note usually pays out more than a 2-year note.
Inverted curves have historically predicted recessions and can serve as a warning indicator. The Federal Reserve of the United States has begun raising interest rates and is projected to do so strongly until 2022.
In certain ways, yes. When the curve is sloping, banks borrow short-term and lend long-term, making money on the difference in rates.
There is no spread to earn between borrowing for two years and collecting interest on 10-year Treasuries if the two-year and 10-year Treasury yields are inverted.
In practice, however, banks borrow and lend at diverse locations along the curve, with average loan and security maturities of fewer than five years.
At two years, they rarely borrow much and lend at ten years. They are more likely to borrow and lend near the front, or short-term, end of the steep yield curve. On Tuesday, the gap between the 3-month and 5-year Treasury notes, as depicted on the Treasury curve, was around 190 basis points US3MUS5Y=RR.
JPMorgan Chase & Co (JPM.N), for example, funds more than half of its balance sheet with low-cost deposits, which have a modest rate of increase. In the fourth quarter, the average rate for all of JPMorgan’s interest-bearing liabilities was merely 0.22 percent. That’s a far cry from the 2.4 percent yield on 2-year Treasuries US2YT=RR on Tuesday.
Many commercial and industrial loans are also floating-rate term loans, or revolving loan facilities with floating rates related to short-term benchmarks, which have risen dramatically this year in expectation of Fed rate hikes.
Banks have predicted that rate hikes will significantly improve their net interest income this year.
find out more
The greater threat to banks is the possibility of a recession, which would reduce consumer spending and make it more difficult for Americans to repay their debts.
When did the yield curve last invert?
On Tuesday, a carefully watched gauge of the yield curve, which serves as one of the bond market’s most reliable recession indicators, inverted, highlighting concerns about the economy as the Federal Reserve considers raising interest rates quickly.
The widely studied differential between 2-year TMUBMUSD02Y,2.464 percent and 10-year Treasury yields TMUBMUSD10Y,2.385 percent has gone below zero on many occasions and is down from around 160 basis points a year ago. The last time the spread flipped was on August 30, 2019, according to Dow Jones Market Data data at 3 p.m.
Traders are reacting to the likelihood that, in order to combat inflation, the Fed would need to deliver a larger-than-normal half-point rate hike, and potentially more, shortly. Chairman Jerome Powell of the Federal Reserve opened the door to boosting benchmark interest rates by more than a quarter percentage point at a time earlier this month, a view shared by other officials. Some argue that hints of progress in the Russia-Ukraine peace talks allow the Fed to tighten as needed.
Despite a rebounding stock market, “bond markets continue to reflect mounting pessimism regarding the outlook for economic growth,” according to Mark Haefele, chief investment officer at UBS Global Wealth Management.
“The likelihood of an abrupt slowdown or recession has increased,” he said in a note Tuesday, “together with the prospect of a faster sequence of Federal Reserve rate hikes and disruptions related to the crisis in Ukraine.”
Because of its predictive power, investors pay close attention to the Treasury yield curve, or the slope of market-based yields across maturities. According to Principal Global Investors, every recession since the 1950s has been preceded by an inversion of the 2s/10s. That was true of the early 1980s recession, which followed former Fed Chairman Paul Volcker’s inflation-fighting efforts, and the early 2000s downturn, which was marked by the dot-com bubble bursting, the 9/11 terrorist attacks, and various corporate-accounting scandals as well as the 2007-2009 Great Recession, which was triggered by a global financial crisis, and the brief 2020 contraction fueled by the pandemic.
Economic downturns, on the other hand, tend to lag behind 2s/10s inversions. Anshul Pradhan and Samuel Earl of Barclays BARC,-0.85 percent said in a note Tuesday that the lag “has been roughly 20 months, and in several instances, it has been greater than two years.”
Inversions have already occurred elsewhere on the US Treasury curve. The spread between the 5- and 7-year Treasury yields and the 10-year Treasury yield, as well as the difference between the 20- and 30-year yields, have all remained below zero.
According to Ben Emons, managing director of global macro strategy at Medley Global Advisors in New York, the 2s/10s spread has been flattening at a quicker rate than it has at any time since the 1980s, and has moved closer to zero than at similar stages throughout previous Fed rate-hike campaigns.
Normally, the curve does not approach zero until after rate hikes have been implemented. Even with only a single quarter-point rate boost under the Fed’s belt, it ended up there.
The graph below, created in February, compares how long it took the 2s/10s to invert ahead of previous recessions to the current pace. This time, the 2s/10s spread has gone toward zero in a matter of months, rather than the years it took during its previous two forays into negative territory.
How long does it take for a recession to end?
A recession is a long-term economic downturn that affects a large number of people. A depression is a longer-term, more severe slump. Since 1854, there have been 33 recessions. 1 Recessions have lasted an average of 11 months since 1945.