Although both GDP and GNP conceptually represent the entire market value of all products and services produced during a given period, they differ in how they define the economy’s scope. GDP is a metric that measures the value of goods and services produced within the country’s geographical borders by both Americans and people from other countries. Only U.S. residents produce goods and services, both domestically and internationally, as measured by GNP.
The switch from GNP to GDP reflected a more appropriate measure of aggregate production in the United States, especially for short-term economic monitoring and analysis. For a variety of reasons, shifting to this as the primary measure of productivity proved beneficial. In the System of National Accounts, a set of worldwide principles for economic accounting, GDP was the fundamental measure of production. Many other countries had adopted GDP as their main indicator, making cross-national comparisons of economic activity more reliable. It also included other economic indices like employment and productivity in a consistent manner. Furthermore, problems with underlying source data for certain income estimates made quantifying GNP difficult. GNP, on the other hand, is a significant and important aggregate, proving particularly valuable for assessments of income sources and uses.
Quiz on the differences between GDP and GNP.
The entire worth of all final goods and services produced inside a country’s borders is referred to as GDP. The total value of products and services generated by a country over a period of time, both within and without its boundaries, is referred to as GNP.
For example, what are GDP and GNP?
The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is a metric that measures the worth of a country’s economic activities. GDP is the sum of the market values, or prices, of all final goods and services produced in an economy during a given time period. Within this seemingly basic concept, however, there are three key distinctions:
- GDP is a metric that measures the value of a country’s output in local currency.
- GDP attempts to capture all final commodities and services generated within a country, ensuring that the final monetary value of everything produced in that country is represented in the GDP.
- GDP is determined over a set time period, usually a year or quarter of a year.
Computing GDP
Let’s look at how to calculate GDP now that we know what it is. GDP is the monetary value of all the goods and services generated in an economy, as we all know. Consider Country B, which exclusively produces bananas and backrubs. In the first year, they produce 5 bananas for $1 each and 5 backrubs worth $6 each. This year’s GDP is (quantity of bananas X price of bananas) + (quantity of backrubs X price of backrubs), or (5 X $1) + (5 X $6) = $35 for the country. The equation grows longer as more commodities and services are created. For every good and service produced within the country, GDP = (quantity of A X price of A) + (quantity of B X price of B) + (quantity of whatever X price of whatever).
To compute GDP in the real world, the market values of many products and services must be calculated.
While GDP’s total output is essential, the breakdown of that output into the economy’s big structures is often just as important.
In general, macroeconomists utilize a set of categories to break down an economy into its key components; in this case, GDP is equal to the total of consumer spending, investment, government purchases, and net exports, as represented by the equation:
- The sum of household expenditures on durable commodities, nondurable items, and services is known as consumer spending, or C. Clothing, food, and health care are just a few examples.
- The sum of spending on capital equipment, inventories, and structures is referred to as investment (I).
- Machinery, unsold items, and homes are just a few examples.
- G stands for government spending, which is the total amount of money spent on products and services by all government agencies.
- Naval ships and government employee wages are two examples.
- Net exports, or NX, is the difference between foreigners’ spending on local goods and domestic residents’ expenditure on foreign goods.
- Net exports, to put it another way, is the difference between exports and imports.
GDP vs. GNP
GDP is just one technique to measure an economy’s overall output. Another technique is to calculate the Gross National Product, or GNP. As previously stated, GDP is the total value of all products and services generated in a country. GNP narrows the definition slightly: it is the total value of all goods and services generated by permanent residents of a country, regardless of where they are located. The important distinction between GDP and GNP is based on how production is counted by foreigners in a country vs nationals outside of that country. Output by foreigners within a country is counted in the GDP of that country, whereas production by nationals outside of that country is not. Production by foreigners within a country is not considered for GNP, while production by nationals from outside the country is. GNP, on the other hand, is the value of goods and services produced by citizens of a country, whereas GDP is the value of goods and services produced by a country’s citizens.
For example, in Country B (shown in ), nationals produce bananas while foreigners produce backrubs.
Figure 1 shows that Country B’s GDP in year one is (5 X $1) + (5 X $6) = $35.
Because the $30 from backrubs is added to the GNP of the immigrants’ home country, the GNP of country B is (5 X $1) = $5.
The distinction between GDP and GNP is theoretically significant, although it is rarely relevant in practice.
GDP and GNP are usually quite close together because the majority of production within a country is done by its own citizens.
Macroeconomists use GDP as a measure of a country’s total output in general.
Growth Rate of GDP
GDP is a great way to compare the economy at two different times in time. This comparison can then be used to calculate a country’s overall output growth rate.
Subtract 1 from the amount obtained by dividing the GDP for the first year by the GDP for the second year to arrive at the GDP growth rate.
This technique of calculating total output growth has an obvious flaw: both increases in the price of products produced and increases in the quantity of goods produced result in increases in GDP.
As a result, determining whether the volume of output is changing or the price of output is changing from the GDP growth rate is challenging.
Because of this constraint, an increase in GDP does not always suggest that an economy is increasing.
For example, if Country B produced 5 bananas value $1 each and 5 backrubs of $6 each in a year, the GDP would be $35.
If the price of bananas rises to $2 next year and the quantity produced remains constant, Country B’s GDP will be $40.
While the market value of Country B’s goods and services increased, the quantity of goods and services produced remained unchanged.
Because fluctuations in GDP are not always related to economic growth, this factor can make comparing GDP from one year to the next problematic.
Real GDP vs. Nominal GDP
Macroeconomists devised two types of GDP, nominal GDP and real GDP, to deal with the uncertainty inherent in GDP growth rates.
- The total worth of all produced goods and services at current prices is known as nominal GDP. This is the GDP that was discussed in the previous parts. When comparing sheer output with time rather than the value of output, nominal GDP is more informative than real GDP.
- The total worth of all produced goods and services at constant prices is known as real GDP.
- The prices used to calculate real GDP are derived from a certain base year.
- It is possible to compare economic growth from one year to the next in terms of production of goods and services rather than the market value of these products and services by leaving prices constant in the computation of real GDP.
- In this way, real GDP removes the effects of price fluctuations from year-to-year output comparisons.
To calculate real GDP in year 3 using year 1 as the base year, use the GDP equation with year 3 quantities and year 1 prices. In this case, real GDP is (10 X $1) + (9 X $6) = $64. In comparison, nominal GDP in year 3 is (10 X $2) + (9 X $6) = $74.
GDP Deflator
Nominal GDP and real GDP convey various aspects of the shift when comparing GDP between years. Nominal GDP takes into account both quantity and price changes. Real GDP, on the other hand, just measures changes in quantity and is unaffected by price fluctuations. Because of this distinction, a third relevant statistic can be calculated once nominal and real GDP have been computed. The GDP deflator is the nominal GDP to real GDP ratio minus one for a particular year. The GDP deflator, in effect, shows how much of the change in GDP from a base year is due to changes in the price level.
Let’s say we want to calculate the GDP deflator for Country B in year 3 using as the base year.
To calculate the GDP deflator, we must first calculate both nominal and real GDP in year 3.
By rearranging the elements in the GDP deflator equation, nominal GDP may be calculated by multiplying real GDP and the GDP deflator.
This equation displays the distinct information provided by each of these output measures.
Changes in quantity are captured by real GDP.
Changes in the price level are captured by the GDP deflator.
Nominal GDP takes into account both price and quantity changes.
You can break down a change in GDP into its component changes in price level and change in quantities produced using nominal GDP, real GDP, and the GDP deflator.
GDP Per Capita
When describing the size and growth of a country’s economy, GDP is the single most helpful number. However, it’s crucial to think about how GDP relates to living standards. After all, a country’s economy is less essential to its residents than the level of living it delivers.
GDP per capita, calculated by dividing GDP by the population size, represents the average amount of GDP received by each individual, and hence serves as an excellent indicator of an economy’s level of life.
The value of GDP per capita is the income of a representative individual because GDP equals national income.
This figure is directly proportional to one’s standard of living.
In general, the higher a country’s GDP per capita, the higher its level of living.
Because of the differences in population between countries, GDP per capita is a more relevant indicator for measuring level of living than GDP.
If a country has a high GDP but a large population, each citizen may have a low income and so live in deplorable circumstances.
A country, on the other hand, may have a moderate GDP but a small population, resulting in a high individual income.
By comparing standard of living among countries using GDP per capita, the problem of GDP division among a country’s residents is avoided.
Y = C + I + G + X + Z
- Net Income (Z) (Net income inflow from abroad minus net income outflow to foreign countries)
The production of physical commodities such as automobiles, agricultural products, machinery, and other machinery, as well as the provision of services such as healthcare, business consulting, and education, are all included in the Gross National Product. Taxes and depreciation are included in GNP. Because the cost of services utilized in the production of items is included in the cost of finished goods, it is not computed separately.
To produce real GNP, Gross National Product must be adjusted for inflation for year-to-year comparisons. GNP is also expressed per capita for country-to-country comparisons. There are challenges in accounting for dual citizenship when computing GNP. If a producer or manufacturer is a dual citizen of two nations, his productive output will be considered by both countries, resulting in double counting.
Importance of GNP
The Gross National Product (GNP) is one of the most important economic statistics used by policymakers. GNP provides vital data on manufacturing, savings, investments, employment, significant company production outputs, and other economic indicators. This data is used by policymakers to create policy papers that legislators use to pass laws. GNP data is used by economists to solve national issues such as inflation and poverty.
GNP becomes a more trustworthy statistic than GDP when assessing the amount of income earned by a country’s citizens independent of their location. Individuals in the globalized economy have various options for earning money, both domestically and internationally. GNP gives information that other productivity measurements do not incorporate when measuring such wide data. GNP would be equal to GDP if people of a country were limited to domestic sources of income, and it would be less valuable to the government and policymakers.
GNP information is also useful for examining the balance of payments. The difference between a country’s exports to foreign countries and the value of the items and services imported determines the balance of payments. When a country has a balance of payments deficit, it indicates it imports more goods and services than it exports. A surplus in the balance of payments indicates that the value of the country’s exports exceeds the value of its imports.
GNP vs. GDP
The market value of items and services produced in the economy is measured by both the Gross National Product (GNP) and the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). GDP reflects domestic levels of production, whereas GNP measures the level of output of a country’s population regardless of their location. The distinction arises from the fact that there may be many domestic enterprises that manufacture things for export, as well as foreign-owned companies that manufacture goods within the country.
GNP exceeds GDP when the income earned by domestic enterprises in foreign nations exceeds the income earned by foreign firms within the country. Because of the large number of manufacturing activities carried out by American people in other nations, the United States’ GNP is $250 billion more than its GDP.
The most common method for measuring economic activity in a country is to use GDP. Until 1991, the United States utilized Gross National Product as its primary indicator of economic activity. The Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) recognized that GDP was a more convenient economic indicator of total economic activity in the United States while making the changes.
The Gross National Product (GNP) is a valuable economic measure, particularly for determining a country’s income from international commerce. When appraising a country’s economic net worth, both economic indicators should be included in order to obtain an accurate picture of the economy.
Gross National Income (GNI)
Large institutions such as the European Union (EU), the World Bank, and the Human Development Index employ Gross National Income (GNI) instead of Gross National Product (HDI). GDP + net revenue from abroad, plus net taxes and subsidies receivable from abroad, is the definition.
The Gross National Income (GNI) is a metric that evaluates how much money a country’s inhabitants make from domestic and international trade. Despite the fact that GNI and GNP serve the same goal, GNI is thought to be a better measure of income than production.
Can GDP and GNP be equal?
To put it another way, GNP is a subset of GDP. While GDP confines its economic analysis to the country’s physical borders, GNP broadens it to include the net abroad economic activity carried out by its citizens. GNP is a measure of how much a country’s citizens contribute to its economy.
What does GNP stand for?
Gross national product (GNP) is the total market value of the final goods and services generated by a nation’s economy over a given time period (typically a year), computed before depreciation or consumption of capital utilized in the production process is taken into account. It differs from net national product, which is calculated after such a deduction has been made. The GNP is almost identical to the GDP.
What is the difference between GDP and GNP, and which is a better indicator of a country’s economic performance?
The quick answer is that GNP is superior since it accounts for long-term investments that return to the country.
The short answer is no. As Joseph Stiglitz points out, these metrics are deceptive because they reveal nothing about the growth’s long-term viability. Environmental degradation and resource depletion are completely neglected. For example, if a country has a trillion dollars worth of trees and removes them all, economic activity will increase, but there will be nothing left the following year.
Finally, measuring economic activity is pointless if we don’t consider how the money is spent. Stiglitz presents an example of a resource misallocation that affects GDP and GNP. Because the United States has 10 times the number of individuals incarcerated as other advanced countries, building and running prisons costs 6% of GDP. It is beneficial to GDP but detrimental to society.
What is the difference between GDP and GNP? Which is more likely to be higher, GDP or GNP, if a country hires numerous foreign workers?
A country that employs a large number of foreign employees is likely to have a negative NFP, implying that GDP exceeds GNP.
Which of the two measures of growth, GDP or GNP, is more accurate?
GDP vs GNP: Which Is the Better Economic Measure? Gross domestic product (GDP) is a more helpful economic indicator than gross national product (GNP), which is primarily used to analyze a country’s people’ total income over a period of time.
Why is Gross Domestic Product (GDP) not a suitable indicator of economic development?
If we repeated this process for all of the products on our list, the total would be gross national disproduct. When the sum is compared to the aggregate of production as measured by GNP, it shows how far we’ve come in terms of social wellbeing. In fact, we’d have our wonderful “social” indication of what the country has accomplished if we could find a true “net” between disproduct and product.
The outcomes would almost certainly be disappointing. We’d probably discover that, while gratifying today’s human desires, we were also producing present and future desires to repair the damage caused by current manufacturing.
Conclusion:
GNP can only reflect the amount of money that society exchanges for commodities since it assesses the market value of final goods and services. As a result, many vital activities that have an impact on our standard of living are left out of the GNP calculation. We include benefits received from the government in GNP but not the expenditures of giving them, for example.
Another example is the social benefit of education but not the costs of obtaining it. As a result, one would be inclined to produce a more accurate assessment of economic output by include both negative and positive production contributions. However, the majority of economists disagree with this approach.