The depth of the Great Recession’s impact, particularly to America’s poor, is still unknown. We’ve discussed the chronically high poverty rate and the importance of TANF in keeping families afloat on this blog. Marianne Bitler and Hilary Hoynes, economists, have written a new article for the 2015 Annual Meeting of the American Economic Association. The authors want to know how economic cycles affect people “both within and across the income distribution.”
In a recession, what happens to income-to-poverty ratios? After dividing after-tax and transfer income by official poverty standards, Bitler and Hoynes arrive at household income-to-poverty ratios (labelled ATTI poverty in figures). Then they calculate what percentage of the population earns less than each level. Finally, for the years 1980 to 2013, they regressed these shares on the unemployment rate.
As the unemployment rate climbs, the percentage of the population with earnings below each level rises as well. However, the amount of the effect varies dramatically across the income-to-poverty distribution, with the bottom of the income-to-poverty distribution being impacted more than the top.
The fact that the effect on those at the very bottom is not as severe as it is for those with 75 percent or 100 percent ATTI poverty is reassuring. However, the main lesson is that recessions can exacerbate the disadvantage of individuals at the bottom of the income distribution.
The writers also examine and contrast the effects of the Great Recession with the 1980s recessions. There are a few major distinctions. The very bottom of the income distribution was spared the brunt of the jobless effect in the 1980s. During the Great Recession, however, the most severe effects of unemployment were felt by those with the lowest income-to-poverty ratios.
Who is the hardest hit by a downturn?
The groups who lost the most jobs during the Great Recession were the same ones that lost jobs throughout the 1980s recessions.
Hoynes, Miller, and Schaller use demographic survey and national time-series data to conclude that the Great Recession has harmed males more than women in terms of job losses. However, their research reveals that men have faced more cyclical labor market outcomes in earlier recessions and recoveries. This is partly due to the fact that men are more likely to work in industries that are very cyclical, such as construction and manufacturing. Women are more likely to work in industries that are less cyclical, such as services and government administration. While the pattern of labor market effects across subgroups in the 2007-9 recession appears to be comparable to that of the two early 1980s recessions, it did have a little bigger impact on women’s employment, while the effects on women were smaller in this recession than in previous recessions. The effects of the recent recession were felt most acutely by the youngest and oldest workers. Hoynes, Miller, and Schaller also discover that, in comparison to the 1980s recovery, the current recovery is affecting males more than women, owing to a decrease in the cyclicality of women’s employment during this period.
The researchers find that the general image of demographic patterns of responsiveness to the business cycle through time is one of stability. Which groups suffered the most job losses during the Great Recession? The same groups that suffered losses during the 1980s recessions, and who continue to have poor labor market outcomes even in good times. As a result, the authors conclude that the Great Recession’s labor market consequences were distinct in size and length from those of past business cycles, but not in type.
During a recession, who suffers the most?
The following is a summary of our findings: First, the Great Recession’s labor market fall is both worse and longer than the recession of the early 1980s. Second, men, black and Hispanic employees, teenagers, and low-education workers have been hit the worst by the Great Recession.
What is the impact of a recession on the typical person?
When manufacturing slows, demand for products and services falls, financing tightens, and the economy enters a recession. People have a poorer standard of life as a result of job insecurity and investment losses.
What occurs when an economy enters a downturn?
- A recession is a period of economic contraction during which businesses experience lower demand and lose money.
- Companies begin laying off people in order to decrease costs and halt losses, resulting in rising unemployment rates.
- Re-employing individuals in new positions is a time-consuming and flexible process that faces certain specific problems due to the nature of labor markets and recessionary situations.
Which state was hardest damaged by the economic downturn?
California lost 890,700 jobs during the course of the decade, or 6.06 percent of its 2000 employment level. California also lost the most employment during the recession of 2008-2009. (1,371,200 jobs).
What industries do best during a downturn?
- While some industries are more vulnerable to economic fluctuations, others tend to do well during downturns.
- However, no organization or industry is immune to a recession or economic downturn.
- During the COVID-19 epidemic, the consumer goods and alcoholic beverage sectors functioned admirably.
- During recessions and other calamities, such as a pandemic, consumer basics such as toothpaste, soap, and shampoo have consistent demand.
- Because their fundamental products are cheaper, discount businesses do exceptionally well during recessions.
A recession favours whom?
Question from the audience: Identify and explain economic variables that may be positively affected by the economic slowdown.
A recession is a time in which the economy grows at a negative rate. It’s a time of rising unemployment, lower salaries, and increased government debt. It usually results in financial costs.
- Companies that provide low-cost entertainment. Bookmakers and publicans are thought to do well during a recession because individuals want to ‘drink their sorrows away’ with little bets and becoming intoxicated. (However, research suggest that life expectancy increases during recessions, contradicting this old wives tale.) Demand for online-streaming and online entertainment is projected to increase during the 2020 Coronavirus recession.
- Companies that are suffering with bankruptcies and income loss. Pawnbrokers and companies that sell pay day loans, for example people in need of money turn to loan sharks.
- Companies that sell substandard goods. (items whose demand increases as income decreases) e.g. value goods, second-hand retailers, etc. Some businesses, such as supermarkets, will be unaffected by the recession. People will reduce their spending on luxuries, but not on food.
- Longer-term efficiency gains Some economists suggest that a recession can help the economy become more productive in the long run. A recession is a shock, and inefficient businesses may go out of business, but it also allows for the emergence of new businesses. It’s what Joseph Schumpeter dubbed “creative destruction” the idea that when some enterprises fail, new inventive businesses can emerge and develop.
- It’s worth noting that in a downturn, solid, efficient businesses can be put out of business due to cash difficulties and a temporary decline in revenue. It is not true that all businesses that close down are inefficient. Furthermore, the loss of enterprises entails the loss of experience and knowledge.
- Falling asset values can make purchasing a home more affordable. For first-time purchasers, this is a good option. It has the potential to aid in the reduction of wealth disparities.
- It is possible that one’s life expectancy will increase. According to studies from the Great Depression, life expectancy increased in areas where unemployment increased. This may seem counterintuitive, but the idea is that unemployed people will spend less money on alcohol and drugs, resulting in improved health. They may do fewer car trips and hence have a lower risk of being involved in fatal car accidents. NPR
The rate of inflation tends to reduce during a recession. Because unemployment rises, wage inflation is moderated. Firms also respond to decreased demand by lowering prices.
Those on fixed incomes or who have cash savings may profit from the decrease in inflation. It may also aid in the reduction of long-term inflationary pressures. For example, the 1980/81 recession helped to bring inflation down from 1970s highs.
After the Lawson boom and double-digit inflation, the 1991 Recession struck.
Efficiency increase?
It has been suggested that a recession encourages businesses to become more efficient or go out of business. A recession might hasten the ‘creative destruction’ process. Where inefficient businesses fail, efficient businesses thrive.
Covid Recession 2020
The Covid-19 epidemic was to blame for the terrible recession of 2020. Some industries were particularly heavily damaged by the recession (leisure, travel, tourism, bingo halls). However, several businesses benefited greatly from the Covid-recession. We shifted to online delivery when consumers stopped going to the high street and shopping malls. Online behemoths like Amazon saw a big boost in sales. For example, Amazon’s market capitalisation increased by $570 billion in the first seven months of 2020, owing to strong sales growth (Forbes).
Profitability hasn’t kept pace with Amazon’s surge in sales. Because necessities like toilet paper have a low profit margin, profit growth has been restrained. Amazon has taken the uncommon step of reducing demand at times. They also experienced additional costs as a result of Covid, such as paying for overtime and dealing with Covid outbreaks in their warehouses. However, due to increased demand for online streaming, Amazon saw fast development in its cloud computing networks. These are the more profitable areas of the business.
Apple, Google, and Facebook all had significant revenue and profit growth during an era when companies with a strong online presence benefited.
The current recession is unique in that there are more huge winners and losers than ever before. It all depends on how the virus’s dynamics effect the firm as well as aggregate demand.
Why did money become scarce during the Great Depression?
During the Great Depression, the money stock decreased mostly due to banking panics. Depositors’ faith that they will be able to access their cash in banks whenever they need them is crucial to banking systems.
How do you get through a downturn?
But, according to Tara Sinclair, an economics professor at George Washington University and a senior fellow at Indeed’s Hiring Lab, one of the finest investments you can make to recession-proof your life is obtaining an education. Those with a bachelor’s degree or higher have a substantially lower unemployment rate than those with a high school diploma or less during recessions.
“Education is always being emphasized by economists,” Sinclair argues. “Even if you can’t build up a financial cushion, focusing on ensuring that you have some training and abilities that are broadly applicable is quite important.”
What causes a downturn?
Most recessions, on the other hand, are brought on by a complex combination of circumstances, such as high interest rates, poor consumer confidence, and stagnant or lower real wages in the job market. Bank runs and asset bubbles are two further instances of recession causes (see below for an explanation of these terms).