- With current moves to raise the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour, raising the minimum wage has been an issue for decades.
- There are differing perspectives on whether increasing the minimum wage causes inflation.
- According to some economists, boosting the minimum wage artificially causes labor market imbalances and contributes to inflation.
- Other economists point out that in the past, when minimum wages were raised, inflation did not follow.
Why hasn’t the minimum wage been raised in line with inflation?
Inflation has not kept pace with the minimum wage. Because the federal minimum wage is not inflation-indexed, its purchasing power (the number of products that can be purchased with one unit of cash) has plummeted since its peak in 1968. In 1968, the minimum salary was $1.60.
Does inflation affect wages?
Despite rising salaries, inflation resulted in a 2.4 percent pay loss for the ordinary worker last year. According to the US Department of Labor, inflation increased by 7% in December from the previous year. Wages climbed by 4.7 percent on average per hour. On average, this translates to a wage decrease of more than 2%.
With inflation, what should the minimum salary be?
Consumer prices rose 5.3 percent in August compared to the previous year, causing some anxiety as the economy recovers from the pandemic. Food prices at home increased by 3%, while food prices away from home (i.e. restaurants) increased by 4.7 percent, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ latest release this week. Rents and energy prices both increased by roughly 9%.
One point of worry for employers and employees in the United States is that activists frequently exploit inflation data to support their campaign for a $15 minimum wage, or even a higher salary of $23 per hour, despite the fact that study shows such steep rises will destroy millions of jobs.
Remember, if we kept up with inflation, the minimum wage would be $23/hr right now. $15 is a good middle ground. #RaiseTheWagehttps://t.co/44l6Rqln0F
Despite the fact that inflation has risen dramatically in the last year, the so-called “The Fight for $15” is still not based on a consumer price index. If the 2009 federal minimum wage increase to $7.25 per hour were indexed to climb with inflation, it would equal $9.22 today, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data up to August 2021.
If the minimum wage were to be adjusted to the level in 1990, it would be $7.17 now. No matter how you slice it, these data don’t even come close to, let alone support, the $23 hourly rate proposed by the union-backed One Fair Wage.
Indeed, the $15 minimum wage goal that several states and municipalities have already enacted has no precedence in history. An organizing director for the Service Employees International Union’s Fight for $15 campaign joked about the absence of genuine analysis informing their main policy goal at one meeting, saying: “We decided that $10 was too low and $20 was too much, so we settled on $15.”
Unfortunately, these draconian minimum wage targets, which lack economic justification, will wreak havoc on firms and employees as they try to recover from the pandemic. According to the impartial Congressional Budget Office, the Raise the Wage Act of 2021, which proposes a $15 minimum wage nationwide, may cost the country up to 2.7 million jobs. According to economists from Miami and Trinity Universities’ industry and state-level analyses, the hospitality and restaurant industries would bear the brunt of these effects. Increases above the $15 minimum wage would have an even bigger negative impact on employer costs, and could result in the loss of many more employment.
Is everyone getting a raise in 2022 when the minimum wage rises?
An economy that works for everyone is necessary for progress and the well-being of working families.
President Biden signed the Minimum Wage Executive Order on April 27, 2021, and the Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division issued the implementing regulations, ensuring that workers on federal contracts are paid a fair wage and demonstrating that the government can lead by example.
We’re boosting the minimum pay for government contract workers to $15.00 per hour beginning January 30, 2022. This rise, which will effect more than 300,000 workers, comes at a time when the federal government is making historic investments in our nation’s infrastructure, which will result in the creation of millions of new jobs in construction and associated industries.
While construction employees will be covered by the $15 minimum wage, workers in child care, health care, and building and other services on government contracts will also be covered. Women make up around 54% of those affected by the minimum wage rise, while workers of color make up roughly 25%. Workers who benefit from our final minimum wage rule will receive an average annual rise of $5,228.
Raising the minimum wage strengthens families’ financial security, decreases poverty, and moves the country closer to reversing decades of income inequality. Better government services, increased morale and productivity, and fewer turnover and absenteeism are all possible additional benefits.
The rule also protects workers on government contracts, in addition to raising the minimum wage:
- Raising the minimum pay for disabled workers who would otherwise earn less than the minimum wage.
- Starting Jan. 1, 2023, federal contract workers who get tips will be paid at least 85 percent of the entire minimum wage in cash, and 100 percent starting Jan. 1, 2024.
- Workers who provide recreational activities on public lands should have their minimum wage rights restored.
As of January 30, 2021, these modifications will apply to most new contracts, including renewals and extensions. They apply to federal contract workers in all 50 states, as well as the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, the Virgin Islands, Outer Continental Shelf lands as defined in the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act, American Samoa, Guam, the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, Wake Island, and Johnston Island, as well as the District of Columbia.
As a government employee, I witness firsthand how the labor of federal contract workers keeps the government functioning and ensures that the American people have access to critical services and resources. Executive Order 14026, which I am happy to sign, will help hundreds of thousands of hardworking people, their families, and our communities.
Would you like to understand more about this rule and what it implications for businesses? On the 26th and 27th of January, register for one of our federal contractor seminars.
Why is inflation so detrimental to the economy?
- Inflation, or the gradual increase in the price of goods and services over time, has a variety of positive and negative consequences.
- Inflation reduces purchasing power, or the amount of something that can be bought with money.
- Because inflation reduces the purchasing power of currency, customers are encouraged to spend and store up on products that depreciate more slowly.
What is creating 2021 inflation?
As fractured supply chains combined with increased consumer demand for secondhand vehicles and construction materials, 2021 saw the fastest annual price rise since the early 1980s.
What effect does inflation have on your pay?
The Pew Research Center’s lead researcher, Rakesh Kochhar, emphasizes that “there is no single metric” of inflation or average worker salaries.
He points out that many part-time workers are left out of these salary increase projections. He also points out that the consumer price index tries to capture what the average American buys, but that this may not be the case for everyone. For example, gas costs have risen dramatically in recent months, putting a greater strain on the budgets of Americans who own automobiles than on those who do not.
According to Kochhar’s most current data, the median wage of all workers has stayed essentially steady around $20 per hour over the past many years when adjusted for inflation.
How do you ask for an inflation increase?
“The rate of inflation is increasing rapidly, and I’d like to talk to you about my existing wage and how we’re making sure that it stays equitable to compete in the current inflation rate,” Mustain suggests starting the conversation with your manager.
You might even bring up the inflation rate later in the meeting to bolster your case for more pay. Remember that your performance is the most essential argument in the conversation whenever you decide to bring it up.
Angelina Darrisaw, a career coach and founder and CEO of C-Suite Coach, advises, “Focus your conversation on the value you bring since that’s ultimately what will convince your employer to give you that wage boost.”
Consider the constraints of your employment and the objectives your supervisor set for you, then describe how you fulfilled or exceeded those objectives. Assume you’re a salesperson with a monthly goal of 30 sales. Make a big deal out of it if you’ve routinely made 35.
Why should the minimum wage be increased?
What impact would raising the minimum wage have on employment? The cost of employing low-paid workers would rise if the minimum wage was raised. As a result, some firms would hire fewer people than they would if the minimum wage were lower. However, employment may increase for specific workers or in certain conditions.
The amount of jobless, not merely unemployed, workers would reflect changes in employment. People who are jobless include both those who have left the labor force (for example, because they believe there are no jobs available for them) and those who are looking for work.
How did the CBO calculate the employment effects? The amount of the effects, according to the CBO, is determined by the number of workers affected by the rise in the minimum wage, wage changes caused by the higher minimum wage, and the responsiveness of employment to those salary changes. If the minimum wage change affected more workers, if it resulted in larger mandated increases for directly affected workers, if firms had more time to respond (for example, because the change was phased in over a longer period), and if the minimum wage was indexed to inflation or wage growth, the effects would be greater in general.
See Appendix A of the CBO’s July 2019 report The Effects on Employment and Family Income of Increasing the Federal Minimum Wage for more information on the CBO’s analysis. Despite the fact that the 2020 coronavirus pandemic and the current recession had an impact on CBO’s baseline budget and economic projections for the years 20212030, CBO has not changed its methods for estimating how employment would respond to a higher minimum wage, in part because CBO expects employment to be near the level it was in the baseline projections underlying the 2019 report in a few years.
How long would people remain jobless if they lost their jobs as a result of a minimum-wage increase? At one extreme, a raise in the minimum wage might permanently lay off a tiny group of workers, preventing them from benefiting from increased pay. On the other hand, a big group of workers may bounce in and out of work on a regular basis, going unemployed for brief periods of time yet earning greater income during the weeks they were worked.
CBO used its estimates of the distribution of unemployment durations for the 20002020 period to assign directly affected workers either no joblessness or a duration of joblessness within the projection year that was randomly chosen from that distribution in analyzing the effects of joblessness on poverty. As a result, some workers in CBO’s analysis are unemployed for over a year, while others are unemployed for significantly shorter lengths of time.
What impact would raising the minimum wage have on family income? A higher minimum wage would increase the real income of low-wage employees who already have jobs, pulling some of those families out of poverty. However, some families’ incomes would suffer as a result of other workers being laid off and business owners having to bear at least some of the higher labor costs. As a result, raising the minimum wage would result in a net decrease in average family income.
What method did the CBO use to calculate the effects on family income? The CBO forecasted future family income distributions and then blended those projections with estimates of wage rates, employment, company income, and prices. Increases in the earnings of individuals who would have earned slightly more than the proposed minimum wage if the policy had not been implemented include increases in the wages of workers who would have earned slightly more than the proposed minimum wage if the policy had not been implemented. Losses in business owners’ income and consumer purchasing power would be somewhat compensated by an improvement in worker productivity as a result of higher pay. (This boost in production could come from a variety of sources, including a decrease in turnover.) See The Effects of Raising the Federal Minimum Wage on Employment and Family Income for further information.)
What impact would raising the minimum wage have on the number of individuals living in poverty? A higher minimum wage would elevate some families’ income beyond the poverty line and so reduce the number of people in poverty by increasing the income of low-paid workers with jobs. Low-wage workers who lose their jobs, on the other hand, will see their earnings plummet, and in certain situations, their family’s income will fall below the poverty line. The first effect would be stronger than the second, resulting in a decrease in the number of individuals living in poverty.
How did the CBO calculate the number of persons living in poverty? The CBO estimated the distribution of poverty in future years using the same methodology it used to project the distribution of family income, using the same definitions of income and poverty criteria as the Census Bureau. According to the CBO, the poverty line will be $21,260 for a family of three and $26,850 for a family of four in 2025 (in 2021 dollars).
What is the probability of these outcomes? The magnitude of any option’s effects on employment and family income is highly unknown. There are two primary causes for this. First, future wage increase is questionable under existing law. If wages grow faster than the CBO predicts, wages will be higher in future years than the CBO predicts, and increases in the federal minimum wage will have a lower impact. The effects would be greater if wages grew more slowly than the CBO predicted.
Second, there is a lot of ambiguity regarding whether or not a raise in the minimum wage will affect employment. Increases in the minimum wage would result in bigger job losses if employment is more responsive than the CBO predicts. If employment is less responsive than the CBO predicts, however, the decreases will be less. The study literature on how changes in the federal minimum wage effect employment reveals a wide range of results. Many studies have found little or no effect, whereas others have discovered significant job losses.
Is it possible that raising the minimum wage will have unintended consequences? Studies have looked at the relationship between minimum wages and a variety of outcomes other than employment and family income, such as labor force participation (whether a person is working or actively looking for work), health outcomes like depression, suicide, and obesity, education outcomes like school completion and job training, and social outcomes like crime. In this research, CBO did not go into the other possible outcomes. However, Appendix B of The Effects on Employment and Family Income of Increasing the Federal Minimum Wage contains a list of sources.
The CBO calculated how a $15 minimum wage option would effect the federal budget in The Budgetary Effects of the Raise the Wage Act of 2021. Changes in macroeconomic factors like inflation and aggregate income were factored into the analysis.
How have the estimations generated by this tool altered as a result of the updates? The current version of the tool produces different results than the first version released in 2019. This is due to two factors. To begin, the alternatives would be introduced in 2022 rather than 2020, though they would be fully implemented on January 1st, 2025, 2026, or 2027, as in the previous version. Under existing law, earnings would grow over time, so any increase in the minimum wage would have a smaller impact on wages, and thus on employment and family income, if it occurred later. Second, because changes in mean salaries are the most important contributor to budgetary effect estimations, the tool now displays mean (rather than median) estimates from distributions of anticipated outcomes. The means are often greater than the medians because those distributions include some really large values. See The Budgetary Effects of the Raise the Wage Act of 2021 for a more in-depth look at these changes.
The CBO also changed the size of incremental changes to the minimum wage leading up to the policy’s target minimum wage. The overall increase in the minimum wage was allocated evenly across the years of a policy’s implementation in the original version of the tool. Annual minimum wage increases are equivalent to those imposed by the Raise the Wage Act of 2021 in the updated edition. As a result, the biggest gains occur in the first year after a policy is implemented.
How does the Raise the Wage Act vary from the default policy option? This interactive’s default option closely resembles the Raise the Wage Act of 2021, which the CBO analyzed in its February 2021 report. The standard minimum, for example, reaches $15 per hour four years after the first incremental increase, the subminimum for tipped workers reaches parity with the regular minimum two years after the regular minimum reaches $15, and both minimums are indexed to changes in median hourly wages once they reach their targets. The key difference is that the first incremental rise occurs on January 1, 2022 in this interactive, whereas it was anticipated for June 1, 2021 in the February 2021 report.
In Canada, has the minimum wage kept up with inflation?
Correction: The original item on January 21, 2020 stated that the hourly wage was $24. On March 16, 2022, a spreadsheet error was discovered and repaired. The data in this page have been revised throughout. For a complete explanation, see Dean Baker’s post.
Until 1968, the minimum wage not only kept pace with inflation, but it also grew in lockstep with productivity. The argument is simple: we anticipate that salaries will rise in lockstep with productivity growth. The minimum wage should rise in tandem with productivity in order for low-paid workers to benefit from the overall improvement in society’s living standards.
It’s crucial to understand the difference between inflation and productivity. If the minimum wage advances in lockstep with inflation, we can be sure that minimum wage people will be able to buy the same quantity of goods and services over time, insulating them from rising prices. If it rises with productivity, however, it means that minimum wage earners will be able to buy more goods and services over time as employees are able to generate more products and services per hour.
While the national minimum wage rose nearly in lockstep with productivity growth from 1938 to 1968, it has not kept up with inflation in the more than five decades since then. If the minimum wage had risen in lockstep with productivity growth since 1968, it would now be about $21.50 an hour, as illustrated in the graph below.