Why Is US Inflation Higher Than Europe?

Global supply variables, such as supply chain disruptions and energy markets (see Exhibit 1), are obviously a part of the reason for recent increases in key inflation indices across advanced economies. Factors such as production or transportation bottlenecks, as well as higher input prices, have contributed to the continuance of this inflationary pressure.

These determinants are largely global in character, and because they are supply-related rather than demand-driven, domestic monetary policy actions are only likely to have a limited impact on them. In short, the sooner supply chain tensions are relieved, the faster inflationary pressures will dissipate across the board.

Exhibit 1: Global supply chain pressures are still strong, but they may be starting to ease – this graph depicts changes in the global supply chain index from September 1997 to December 2021.

Why is inflation in the United States so high?

Inflation isn’t going away anytime soon. In fact, prices are rising faster than they have been since the early 1980s.

According to the most current Consumer Price Index (CPI) report, prices increased 7.9% in February compared to the previous year. Since January 1982, this is the largest annualized increase in CPI inflation.

Even when volatile food and energy costs were excluded (so-called core CPI), the picture remained bleak. In February, the core CPI increased by 0.5 percent, bringing the 12-month increase to 6.4 percent, the most since August 1982.

One of the Federal Reserve’s primary responsibilities is to keep inflation under control. The CPI inflation report from February serves as yet another reminder that the Fed has more than enough grounds to begin raising interest rates and tightening monetary policy.

“I believe the Fed will raise rates three to four times this year,” said Larry Adam, Raymond James’ chief investment officer. “By the end of the year, inflation might be on a definite downward path, negating the necessity for the five-to-seven hikes that have been discussed.”

Following the reopening of the economy in 2021, supply chain problems and pent-up consumer demand for goods have drove up inflation. If these problems are resolved, the Fed may not have as much work to do in terms of inflation as some worry.

Is European inflation higher than American inflation?

Following a drop in 2020, headline inflation in the United States and the eurozone has risen sharply in recent months (Chart A). In both the United States and the euro area, base effects due to the recovery of energy prices from last year’s decline have played a significant part in this increase.

However, the recent rise in headline inflation in the United States has been far more dramatic than in the euro area, as evidenced by the evolution of price levels in the United States and the euro area. In the euro area, headline inflation and inflation excluding energy and food are both roughly 2% higher than they were before the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic (December 2019), whereas they are around 6% higher in the US (Chart B).

In recent months, headline inflation has been driven by a limited number of products with extremely high inflation rates, including energy prices, particularly in the United States. The “trimmed means” of US CPI and euro area HICP inflation, which eliminate the items with the highest and lowest inflation rates, are examples of this (Chart A). Trimmed mean headline inflation climbed by roughly 1.0 percentage point for the US CPI and 0.8 percentage point for the euro area HICP from January to July 2021. Unadjusted US headline CPI inflation climbed by 4.0 percentage points over that time, whereas HICP inflation jumped by 1.3 percentage points in the euro area.

Why is European inflation so low?

Core inflation in the euro area began around one percentage point lower than in the United States, accounting for roughly half of the present inflation gap. It’s also worth noting that low inflation in the Eurozone before to the pandemic was a terrible thing: Economists agree that monetary authorities should aim for slightly positive inflation of at least 2% to provide them space to decrease interest rates during recessions. Inflation in Europe has been low because politicians have continuously been overly cautious.

However, what about the other half of the inflation gap? As I previously stated, I’ve gone down several rabbit holes and still don’t have an answer. But it’s possible that I was looking for too much precision. After all, reported inflation rates within the euro area differ greatly, with Germany’s around a point and a half higher than France’s and Italy’s. These disparities may have actual economic reasons, but how much of it is statistical noise?

“To say that net output today is greater, but the price level is lower, than 10 years ago or one year ago is a proposition of a similar character to the statement that Queen Victoria was a better queen but not a happier woman than Queen Elizabeth a proposition not without meaning and not without interest, but unsuitable as material for the differentia,” John Maynard Keynes wrote in his magnum opus, “The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money.” Although Keynes was making a poor case for measuring everything in wage units, I’ve always remembered that line as a warning against taking economic metrics too seriously.

With the case of inflation, I’d suggest the moral of the narrative is not to get too caught up in the newest print’s international variances. The essential fact is that numerous countries have had similar inflation spikes. That informs you that what’s going on in the US isn’t primarily about policy.

What is creating 2021 inflation?

As fractured supply chains combined with increased consumer demand for secondhand vehicles and construction materials, 2021 saw the fastest annual price rise since the early 1980s.

RELATED: Inflation: Gas prices will get even higher

Inflation is defined as a rise in the price of goods and services in an economy over time. When there is too much money chasing too few products, inflation occurs. After the dot-com bubble burst in the early 2000s, the Federal Reserve kept interest rates low to try to boost the economy. More people borrowed money and spent it on products and services as a result of this. Prices will rise when there is a greater demand for goods and services than what is available, as businesses try to earn a profit. Increases in the cost of manufacturing, such as rising fuel prices or labor, can also produce inflation.

There are various reasons why inflation may occur in 2022. The first reason is that since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, oil prices have risen dramatically. As a result, petrol and other transportation costs have increased. Furthermore, in order to stimulate the economy, the Fed has kept interest rates low. As a result, more people are borrowing and spending money, contributing to inflation. Finally, wages have been increasing in recent years, putting upward pressure on pricing.

Is Europe affected by inflation?

  • In the last few days, Bundesbank Governor Joachim Nagel has become the second central banker to suggest that the ECB may raise rates later this year.
  • Annual inflation in the euro area is expected to grow from 2.6 percent in 2021 to 3.5 percent in 2022, before falling to 1.7 percent in 2023, according to the commission.
  • Inflationary expectations, as well as the European economy as a whole, are influenced by tensions between Ukraine and Russia.

Is there inflation in Europe?

The European Commission warned on Thursday that inflation in euro-area countries, which has rocketed to new highs in recent months, is projected to peak in the first quarter of this year, as consumers feel the pinch of increased energy prices and growing costs of essential commodities.

According to the European Commission’s quarterly economic projection, inflation in the euro area will reach 4.8 percent in January-March, up from 4.6 percent in the fourth quarter of last year, which was a record since the union began measuring inflation collectively in 1997. Inflation is predicted to fall this year, but it won’t reach the European Central Bank’s objective of 2% until 2023, according to the prediction.

As the effects of the epidemic fade, economies will continue to thrive, with the euro area set to increase by 4% this year, according to projections, and will have recovered all of their pandemic-era economic losses by the end of the year.

Inflation, on the other hand, will surpass the average rate of economic progress, diminishing gains and advantages that such growth would otherwise provide to Europeans.

Is hyperinflation a possibility in the United States?

Inflation has returned. Despite the fact that rates are likely to fall in 2022, Martin Paick and Juraj Falath note that there is a lot of uncertainty, and the Fed needs to act now to prevent having to reverse course later.

Despite the fact that some price rises were anticipated, US inflation rates have routinely exceeded economists’ estimates. Seven of the last ten CPI inflation numbers shocked economists to the upside, but none to the downside. New COVID mutations that are more transmissible, slower vaccine rollouts (creating supply bottlenecks in emerging nations), decreased vaccine efficacy, supply chain disruptions, climatic hazards, and rising property and energy prices are all potential risks.

Inflationary pressures that persist are unfavorable for debtors. A little degree of inflation above target could help countries restructure their debt and wipe out some of the record government debt burden. If inflation spirals out of control and central banks are forced to slam on the brakes by hiking interest rates sharply, those record debt levels would hurt even more. Furthermore, stifling economic activity too severely risks triggering a new recession.

Inflation soared because of COVID

To determine if we should be concerned about inflation, we must first examine the current sources of inflationary pressures. The only source of inflation that should prompt a contractionary macroeconomic policy response (either monetary by raising interest rates or fiscal by reducing budget deficits) is inflation caused by the labor market. There is a risk of “overheating” when workers have enough bargaining strength to win a pay raise that exceeds the economy’s long-term potential. Only in this case, where wage growth exceeds productivity growth, should macroeconomic policy be intervened. Other supply-side causes of inflation, such as commodity prices, are very volatile and largely determined by global markets. These inflationary pressures are unlikely to be permanent because they are not the product of overheating.

Energy costs and variables related with the reopening of the US economy were the key drivers of inflation at the start of 2021. Both of these things are usually just transient. However, since the second quarter of 2021, CPI inflation has been increasingly driven by increases in the pricing of core items that are unrelated to the reopening (Figure 1, green columns). This could point to the fact that inflation is becoming more persistent.

Figure 1 shows the impact of reopening and other factors on CPI inflation in the United States (month-on-month in per cent)

Source: Bloomberg, based on my own calculations. Food away from home, used automobiles and trucks, car and truck rental, housing away from home, motor vehicle insurance, and airline cost are all included in the CPI’s reopening component. The rest of the COICOP categories are included in the non-reopening component.

The globe is currently experiencing the worst energy crisis in decades. Gas and power rates have reached all-time highs. This can be considered as part of a compensation for the extreme price drops in 2020, which drove several factories to shut down. The removal of limits increased commodity demand, resulting in higher energy costs. Emission allowances have become more expensive, resulting in a type of green tax. The need for natural gas and oil is increasing as winter approaches. Because supplies are limited, the severity of the crisis will be determined by how cold it becomes.

What we call to as reopening factors have been the second major contributor to headline inflation. Demand has rebounded in contact-sensitive sectors such as vehicle sales, transportation, recreation and culture, holidays, and restaurants as social alienation has reduced. As a result of the battle to supply this pent-up demand and process stockpiled orders, prices began to rise. Reopening triggered inflationary pressures on both the supply and demand sides. Production bottlenecks were caused by a paucity of crucial components in the automobile sector, as well as expensive energy. When demand for cars was low, some chipmakers redirected deliveries to mobile operators. The scarcity of chips available to carmakers pushed vehicle costs up as it started to recover.

Labour markets are much tighter than employment data suggests

We need to look at labor market developments to assess the inflation picture. In general, the unemployment rate decreases as the economy recovers. Workers get more bargaining power as labor demand rises, allowing them to negotiate higher compensation. Their achievement will have an impact on inflation, as higher labor expenses may be passed on to consumers in the form of higher product prices. This can result in a downward price-wage spiral.

More persons chose to remain in retirement, either to health issues or a re-evaluation of life goals.

The labor market in the United States is much tighter than it appears, despite the fact that there are 4.7 million fewer employed employees than before the pandemic. With unemployment at 4.2 percent, there is still a long way to go before reaching the pre-pandemic low of 3.5 percent. The majority of the tightness stems from a drop in participation. Some people were able to retire early or take a temporary hiatus from work because to generous fiscal handouts such as childcare benefits or direct checks to American families. However, a large portion of the reduction in participation was attributable to fewer previously retired people returning to work. More of those people choose to remain in retirement, owing to health issues or a re-evaluation of their life goals. Jobs are plentiful, with 10.4 million opportunities in September. When combined with the historically high percentage of Americans quitting their employment voluntarily, this indicates high job market confidence and, as a result, tight labor markets. Wage inflation is likely to persist as businesses compete for workers who have a choice of occupations.

In the long run, the highest rate of wage increase that can be sustained is equal to the central bank’s inflation target (2% in the US) plus possible productivity growth. Given that this rate in the United States is projected to be about 1.5 percent, nominal wages can rise by about 3.5 percent year over year without worrying about inflation exceeding the objective. In October, average hourly earnings in the United States increased by 4.9 percent year over year, indicating that workers are increasingly able to demand better pay. This is different from the past, when wages did not begin to rise until the recovery was nearing its end. Even more strangely, low-wage workers have benefited the most from the recovery. While this is wonderful news, it could also mean slightly higher inflation in the long run because low-wage employees spend disproportionately on essential commodities.

Markets still on team transitory with more upside risks

Prices are influenced by what consumers and businesses expect, as well as the current situation of the economy. People will demand greater wages in the negotiation process if they predict more inflation. Firms may then try to pass the cost on to customers in the form of higher prices. This is less of an issue for them during times of high demand.

Inflation is expected to rise in the short future, according to financial markets. Long-term expectations in the United States are beginning to de-anchor, with 5y5y forward swaps topping 2.5 percent (Figure 2). The de-anchoring of expectations could have serious effects if they remain high or rise much higher.

Median inflation estimates can be of limited help when the severity of the problem and the desired policy response are dependent on inflation drivers and tail risks. A closer examination of expectations reveals that there is still a modest (but not insignificant) probability that average inflation will exceed 4% during the next five years (Figure 3, red area). The markets, on the other hand, continue to assume that inflation of 2.5-4 percent on average over the next five years is the most likely scenario (Figure 3, dark yellow area). This could lead the Fed to slam on the brakes in the future in order to keep inflation under control. The flattening of the yield curve further supports the idea that the Fed committed a policy blunder by adopting such a lax policy. Although markets anticipate some interest rate hikes in the near future, a rate reversal signals that the transition to neutral rates will be bumpy.

Figure 3: Future inflation probabilities determined from inflation alternatives (average expected inflation for the next 5 years)

The Fed is on the brink of a policy mistake

The inflation rise is consistent with most economic theories, given the unique character of the crisis and the fact that inflationary pressures are mostly originating from the supply side. The key question currently facing central banks is whether increased inflation will become permanent. If employees continue to earn larger wages, this could happen. The de-anchoring of inflation expectations from the central bank aim is another reason why inflation could become entrenched. According to popular belief, if inflation is driven by temporary circumstances, it cannot endure for a long time. These two mechanisms, on the other hand, call this premise into question. Neither may be easily remedied, and each may necessitate a policy shift by central banks. Right now, the greatest danger is not hyperinflation, but long-term high inflation.

Huge quantities of fiscal stimulus, particularly in the form of generous unemployment benefits and checks to low- and middle-income families, have sown the seeds of inflation. Savings have been boosted even more by historic returns in resurgent stock markets, which have benefited Americans in particular. In the near future, this, together with pent-up demand, is anticipated to exert upward pressure on pricing.

Should we thus dismiss Joe Biden’s Build Back Better plan as adding more fuel to the inflation fire? Certainly not. For the first time, a significant portion of the bill is aimed at increasing labor market participation by providing childcare for working families. One of the major concerns about current inflation might be resolved by making it simpler for people to return to work, thereby alleviating labor shortages.

The true danger of escalating inflation outweighs the fact that the US is still not at full employment.

The central bank’s alternatives are restricted. To speed up deliveries, the Fed can’t produce missing semiconductors, mine more oil, or build faster ships. It’s possible that reducing pent-up demand is the way to proceed. However, because the US is still far from full employment, the Fed’s self-imposed benchmark for reducing stimulus, the dual mission complicates things. Furthermore, following the most recent strategy review, full employment should be inclusive as well. This criterion will not be met anytime soon, as Hispanic and Black minorities have been disproportionately affected by the COVID recession.

The real risk of inflation becoming entrenched, in our opinion, outweighs the fact that the United States is still far from full employment. This is a once-in-a-lifetime chance for fiscal and monetary policy to come together. While the monetary side may stop pumping cash into the system, so dampening demand, the fiscal side could much more effectively encourage workforce participation, assisting the Fed in meeting its full employment aim.

In the end, the credibility of the Fed will be critical. Open dialogue and self-reflection are the first steps. The Fed should be candid about why it miscalculated inflation persistence and adjust its assessment of future risks. The recent decision to accelerate the withdrawal of stimulus is a significant step toward recovering credibility and trust in the Fed’s ability to control inflation. The Fed has removed the word “transitory” from its vocabulary, admitting inflation as the number one enemy and signaling speedier rate hikes as an early sign of self-reflection. However, it should do more now in order to avoid having to slam on the brakes later.

In 2021, which country will have the highest inflation rate?

Venezuela has the world’s highest inflation rate, with a rate that has risen past one million percent in recent years. Prices in Venezuela have fluctuated so quickly at times that retailers have ceased posting price tags on items and instead urged consumers to just ask employees how much each item cost that day. Hyperinflation is an economic crisis caused by a government overspending (typically as a result of war, a regime change, or socioeconomic circumstances that reduce funding from tax collection) and issuing massive quantities of additional money to meet its expenses.

Venezuela’s economy used to be the envy of South America, with high per-capita income thanks to the world’s greatest oil reserves. However, the country’s substantial reliance on petroleum revenues made it particularly vulnerable to oil price swings in the 1980s and 1990s. Oil prices fell from $100 per barrel in 2014 to less than $30 per barrel in early 2016, sending the country’s economy into a tailspin from which it has yet to fully recover.

Sudan had the second-highest inflation rate in the world at the start of 2022, at 340.0 percent. Sudanese inflation has soared in recent years, fueled by food, beverages, and an underground market for US money. Inflationary pressures became so severe that protests erupted, leading to President Omar al-ouster Bashir’s in April 2019. Sudan’s transitional authorities are now in charge of reviving an economy that has been ravaged by years of mismanagement.

Why is Canadian inflation so high?

Food prices in grocery stores increased 6.5 percent year over year, compared to 5.7 percent in December, as supply fell short of demand following a period of difficult growing conditions around the world. Food prices are also rising due to higher shipping costs resulting from various supply system interruptions, according to Statistics Canada.

The price of gasoline remained a major factor in total inflation. Prices climbed by more than 30% in January 2021, as oil prices soared amid fears that Russia was about to invade Ukraine, exacerbating the most volatile period of geopolitics since the Cold War ended.

“Simply put, the Bank of Canada is much too hot for comfort, therefore expect a continuous succession of rate hikes in the future sessions,” said Douglas Porter, chief economist at BMO Capital Markets, in a note to clients. “To begin, we look for four in a row, but it may take much more than that to bring inflation to heel.”