Low inflation typically indicates that demand for products and services is lower than it should be, slowing economic growth and lowering salaries. Low demand might even trigger a recession, resulting in higher unemployment, as we witnessed during the Great Recession a decade ago.
Deflation, or price declines, is extremely harmful. Consumers will put off buying while prices are falling. Why buy a new washing machine today if you could save money by waiting a few months?
Deflation also discourages lending because lower interest rates are associated with it. Lenders are unlikely to lend money at rates that provide them with a low return.
When inflation is too low, why is that bad?
The Federal Reserve has not set a formal inflation target, but policymakers usually consider that a rate of roughly 2% or somewhat less is acceptable.
Participants in the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), which includes members of the Board of Governors and presidents of Federal Reserve Banks, make projections for how prices of goods and services purchased by individuals (known as personal consumption expenditures, or PCE) will change over time four times a year. The FOMC’s longer-run inflation projection is the rate of inflation that it considers is most consistent with long-term price stability. The FOMC can then use monetary policy to help keep inflation at a reasonable level, one that is neither too high nor too low. If inflation is too low, the economy may be at risk of deflation, which indicates that prices and possibly wages are declining on averagea phenomena linked with extremely weak economic conditions. If the economy declines, having at least a minor degree of inflation makes it less likely that the economy will suffer from severe deflation.
The longer-run PCE inflation predictions of FOMC panelists ranged from 1.5 percent to 2.0 percent as of June 22, 2011.
Why is it beneficial for people to have low inflation?
Inflation is beneficial when it counteracts the negative impacts of deflation, which are often more damaging to an economy. Consumers spend today because they expect prices to rise in the future, encouraging economic growth. Managing future inflation expectations is an important part of maintaining a stable inflation rate.
Costs of Inflation
The MPC was given a CPI target of 2. percent +/-1 by the government. It feels that inflation of more than 3.0 percent could be harmful to the economy.
- Relative competitiveness is slipping. If inflation in the UK is higher than it is elsewhere, UK goods will become uncompetitive, causing demand for UK exports to plummet. If demand for exports declines, the current account Balance of Payments may have a deficit. However, a devaluation that is anticipated to occur as a result of rising inflation could offset this.
- If global inflation is caused by an increase in oil prices (as it was in 2008), the 2 percent inflation objective may need to be revised or at the very least, a higher inflation rate tolerated. Because every country will experience higher inflation, the UK would maintain its competitive advantage. Reduced inflation could lead to stagflation (lower growth and higher prices). In other words, reducing inflation would be more destructive than tolerating a short increase.
- The currency rate has depreciated. If inflation is excessive, the exchange rate will devalue, which the government wants to avoid because it creates uncertainty among businesses and reduces the purchasing power of Sterling abroad.
- The price of the menu. Menu costs may rise as a result of higher inflation rates, forcing businesses to update their pricing lists frequently. However, when inflation is merely 5%, this is not a big difference. Firms have also found it easier to modify prices thanks to modern technology.
- Economic booms and busts are natural occurrences. If unsustainable economic growth causes inflation, the economic boom may be followed by a recession. The B of E will have to raise interest rates to cut inflation and maintain it within the target range; this will generate problems because AD will decline, resulting in slower growth. For example, in the late 1980s, fast economic expansion in the United Kingdom caused demand-pull inflation, which led to increased interest rates and the boom turning into a collapse.
- Uncertainty is created. Higher inflation rates are despised by businesses because they make forecasting future expenses more difficult. As a result, investment will be reduced. In general, countries with lower inflation rates experience slower economic growth.
- A high rate of inflation would make joining the Euro more difficult, as it would violate the Maastricht criteria. If the UK’s inflation rate was higher than that of Europe, a unified monetary policy would be ineffectual. This is no longer a concern for the UK, as participation in the Eurozone is highly doubtful.
- Redistribution. Inflation may cause income to be redistributed from savers to borrowers. This is due to the fact that inflation lowers the value of money. This, however, is dependent on the interest rate. For example, if the interest rate was 8% and inflation was 5%, savers would still earn a real interest rate of 3%. However, interest rates in many countries were relatively low (0.5 percent) between 2009 and 2017, which meant that even moderate increases in inflation (3-4 percent) resulted in a decrease in the value of savings.
- Wages in real terms It all hinges on whether or not salaries stay up with inflation. Real wages would be dropping if wages increased by 2% and inflation by 4%. This occurred in the United Kingdom between 2009 and 2017.
- Hyperinflation. When inflation begins to rise at a rapid rate, the economy becomes increasingly unstable. Countries that experienced hyperinflation (Zimbabwe in the 2000s, Germany in 1923) saw their economies ravaged by price fluctuations. It creates insecurity and causes people to lose their savings. Hyperinflationary costs can be found here.
Costs of Low Inflation / Deflation
- If prices decline as AS swings to the right as a result of new technology, this is good for the economy since growth will increase and jobs will be generated.
- If dropping AD causes deflation, this is a major economic concern since it signals a recession, which brings problems like unemployment, lower output, and a negative multiplier impact.
- Deflation can be harmful to the economy. It means that people who are in debt will see their debts’ actual worth rise, resulting in weaker consumer confidence and, potentially, lower AD and economic growth.
- Monetary policy becomes inefficient when there is deflation. This is due to the fact that interest rates cannot be dropped below 0%.
- Workers are extremely resistive to any reduction in nominal wage wages, therefore companies can’t readily change actual wages. As a result, real earnings may increase.
Is low inflation beneficial or harmful?
Inflation that is low, consistent, and predictable is good for the economyand your money. It aids in the preservation of money’s worth and makes it easier for everyone to plan how, where, and when they spend.
Companies, for example, are more likely to expand their operations if they know what their costs will be in the coming years. This allows the economy to grow at a steady rate, resulting in better salaries and additional jobs.
Why don’t we desire zero inflation?
Inflation has a variety of economic costs – uncertainty, decreased investment, and redistribution of wealth from savers to borrowers but, despite these costs, is zero inflation desirable?
Inflation is frequently targeted at roughly 2% by governments. (The UK CPI objective is 2% +/-.) There are good reasons to aim for 2% inflation rather than 0% inflation. The idea is that achieving 0% inflation will need slower economic development and result in deflationary problems (falling prices)
Potential problems of deflation/low inflation
- Debt’s true value is increasing. With low inflation, people find it more difficult to repay their debts than they anticipated they must spend a bigger percentage of their income on debt repayments, leaving less money for other purposes.
- Real interest rates are rising. Whether we like it or not, falling inflation raises real interest rates. Rising real interest rates make borrowing and investing less appealing, encouraging people to save. If the economy is in a slump, a rise in real interest rates could make monetary policy less effective at promoting growth.
- Purchase at a later date. Falling prices may motivate customers to put off purchasing pricey luxury products for a year, believing that prices would be lower.
- Inflationary pressures are a sign of slowing economy. Inflation would normally be moderate during a normal period of economic expansion (2 percent ). If inflation has dropped to 0%, it indicates that there is strong price pressure to promote spending and that the recovery is weak.
- Prices and wages are more difficult to modify. When inflation reaches 2 percent, relative prices and salaries are easier to adapt because firms can freeze pay and prices – effectively a 2 percent drop in real terms. However, if inflation is zero, a company would have to decrease nominal pay by 2% – this is far more difficult psychologically because people oppose wage cuts more than they accept a nominal freeze. If businesses are unable to adjust wages, real wage unemployment may result.
Evaluation
There are several reasons for the absence of inflation. The drop in UK inflation in 2015 was attributed to temporary short-term factors such as lower oil and gasoline prices. These transient circumstances are unlikely to persist and have been reversed. The focus should be on underlying inflationary pressures core inflation, which includes volatile food and oil costs. Other inflation gauges, such as the RPI, were 1 percent (even though RPI is not the same as core inflation.) In that situation, inflation fell during a period of modest economic recovery. Although inflation has decreased, the economy has not entered a state of recession. In fact, the exact reverse is true.
Inflation was near to zero in several southern Eurozone economies from 2012 to 2015, although this was due to decreased demand, austerity, and attempts to re-establish competitiveness, which resulted in lower rates of economic growth and more unemployment.
It all depends on what kind of deflation you’re talking about. Real incomes could be boosted by falling prices. One of the most common concerns about deflation is that it reduces consumer spending. However, as the price of basic needs such as gasoline and food falls, consumers’ discretionary income/spending power rises, potentially leading to increased expenditure in the near term.
Wages that are realistic. Falling real earnings have been a trend of recent years, with inflation outpacing nominal wage growth. Because nominal wage growth is still low, the decrease in inflation will make people feel better about themselves and may promote spending. It is critical for economic growth to stop the decline in real wages.
Expectations for the future. Some economists believe that the decline in UK inflation is mostly due to temporary factors, while others are concerned that the ultra-low inflation may feed into persistently low inflation expectations, resulting in zero wage growth and sustained deflationary forces. This is the main source of anxiety about a 0% inflation rate.
Do we have a plan to combat deflation? There is a belief that we will be able to overcome any deflation or disinflation. However, Japan’s history demonstrates that once deflation has set in, it can be quite difficult to reverse. Reducing inflation above target is very simple; combating deflation, on the other hand, is more of a mystery.
Finances of the government In the short term, the decrease in inflation is beneficial to the government. Index-linked benefits will rise at a slower rate than predicted, reducing the UK government’s benefit bill. This might save the government a significant amount of money, reducing the deficit and freeing up funds for pre-election tax cuts.
Low inflation, on the other hand, may result in decreased government tax collections. For example, the VAT (percentage) on items will not rise as much as anticipated. Low wage growth will also reduce tax revenue.
Consumers are frequently pleased when there is little inflation. They will benefit from lower pricing and the feeling of having more money to spend. This ‘feel good’ component may stimulate increased confidence, which could lead to increased investment, spending, and growth. Low inflation could be enabling in disguise in the current context.
However, there is a real risk that if we get stuck in a time of ultra-low inflation/deflation, all of the difficulties associated with deflation would become more visible and begin to stifle regular economic growth.
Why do governments want inflation to be low?
Almost every economist recommends keeping inflation low. Low inflation promotes economic stability, which fosters saving, investment, and economic growth while also assisting in the preservation of international competitiveness.
Governments normally aim for a rate of inflation of around 2%. This moderate but low rate of inflation is thought to be the optimal compromise between avoiding inflation costs while also avoiding deflationary costs (when prices fall)
Benefits of low inflation
To begin with, if inflation is low and stable, businesses will be more confident and hopeful about investing, resulting in increased productive capacity and future greater rates of economic growth.
There could be an economic boom if inflation is allowed to rise due to permissive monetary policy, but if this economic growth is above the long run average rate of growth, it is likely to be unsustainable, and the bubble will be followed by a crash (recession)
After the Lawson boom of the late 1980s, this happened in the UK in 1991. As a result, keeping inflation low will assist the economy avoid cyclical oscillations, which can lead to negative growth and unemployment.
If UK inflation is higher than elsewhere, UK goods will become uncompetitive, resulting in a drop in exports and possibly a worsening of the current account of the balance of payments. Low inflation and low production costs allow a country to remain competitive over time, enhancing exports and competitiveness.
Inflationary expenses include menu costs, which are the costs of updating price lists. When inflation is low, the costs of updating price lists and searching around for the best deals are reduced.
How to achieve low inflation
- Policy monetary. The Central Bank can boost interest rates if inflation exceeds its target. Higher interest rates increase borrowing costs, restrict lending, and lower consumer expenditure. This decreases inflationary pressure while also moderating economic growth.
- Control the supply of money. Monetarists emphasize regulating the money supply because they believe there is a clear link between money supply increase and inflation. See also: Why does an increase in the money supply produce inflation?
- Budgetary policy. If inflation is high, the government can use tight fiscal policy to minimize inflationary pressures (e.g. higher income tax will reduce consumer spending). Inflation is rarely controlled through fiscal policy.
- Productivity growth/supply-side policies Supply-side strategies can lessen some inflationary pressures in the long run. For example, powerful labor unions were criticised in the 1970s for being able to raise salaries, resulting in wage pull inflation. Wage growth has been lower and inflation has been lower as a result of weaker unions.
- Commodity prices are low. Some inflationary forces are beyond the Central Bank’s or government’s control. Cost-push inflation is virtually always a result of rising oil costs, and it’s a difficult problem to tackle.
Problems of achieving low inflation
If a central bank raises interest rates to combat inflation, aggregate demand will decline, economic growth would slow, and a recession and more unemployment may occur.
The Conservative administration, for example, hiked interest rates and adopted a tight budgetary policy in the early 1980s. This cut inflation, but it also contributed to the devastating recession of 1981, which resulted in 3 million people losing their jobs.
Monetarists, on the other hand, believe that inflation may be minimized without compromising other macroeconomic goals. This is because they believe that the Long Run Aggregate Supply is inelastic, and that any decrease in AD will only result in a brief drop in Real GDP, with the economy returning to full employment within a short period.
Can inflation be too low?
Since the financial crisis of 2008, global inflation rates have been low, but some economists claim that this has resulted in sluggish economic growth in the Eurozone and elsewhere.
Japan’s experience in the 1990s demonstrated that extremely low inflation can lead to a slew of significant economic issues. Inflation was quite low in the 1990s and 2000s, but Japan’s GDP was well below its long-term norm, and unemployment was rising. Rising unemployment has a number of negative consequences, including rising inequality, more government borrowing, and an increase in social problems. Even if it conflicts with increased inflation, economic expansion is perhaps a more significant goal in this scenario.
Economists have expressed concerned about the Eurozone’s exceptionally low inflation rates from 2010 to 2017. Deflation has occurred in countries such as Greece and Spain, but unemployment rates have risen to over 25%.
Low inflation usually provides a number of advantages that assist the economy perform better, such as greater investment.
In other cases, though, keeping inflation low may be detrimental to the economy. Maintaining the inflation target in the face of a supply-side shock to the economy could result in higher unemployment and slower development, both of which are undesirable outcomes. As a result, the government should aim for low inflation while being flexible if this looks to be unsuited in the current economic context.
What factors reduce inflation?
- Governments can fight inflation by imposing wage and price limits, but this can lead to a recession and job losses.
- Governments can also use a contractionary monetary policy to combat inflation by limiting the money supply in an economy by raising interest rates and lowering bond prices.
- Another measure used by governments to limit inflation is reserve requirements, which are the amounts of money banks are legally required to have on hand to cover withdrawals.
Why is low inflation preferable than none?
Low inflation is preferable because an economy with no growth in inflation (or zero inflation) risks deflation. Reduced pricing equals less production and lower pay, which pushes prices to fall even more, resulting in even lower wages, and so on.
What happens if inflation falls to 0%?
Deflation is a drop in the overall price level of products and services in economics. When the inflation rate goes below 0%, it is called deflation (a negative inflation rate). Inflation lowers the value of money over time, whereas deflation raises it. This enables for the purchase of more goods and services with the same amount of money as before. Deflation is distinct from disinflation, which is a slowing of the inflation rate, i.e. when inflation falls but remains positive.
A sudden deflationary shock, economists say, is a concern in a contemporary economy because it raises the actual value of debt, especially if the deflation is unanticipated. Deflation can worsen recessions and trigger a deflationary spiral.
Some economists believe that protracted deflationary periods are linked to an economy’s underlying technical advancement, because as productivity (TFP) rises, the cost of things falls.
Deflation usually occurs when supply is high (excess production), demand is low (consumption falls), or the money supply is reduced (often in response to a contraction caused by reckless investment or a credit crunch), or when the economy experiences a net capital outflow. It can also happen as a result of too much competition and insufficient market concentration.
What happens if inflation gets out of control?
If inflation continues to rise over an extended period of time, economists refer to this as hyperinflation. Expectations that prices will continue to rise fuel inflation, which lowers the real worth of each dollar in your wallet.
Spiraling prices can lead to a currency’s value collapsing in the most extreme instances imagine Zimbabwe in the late 2000s. People will want to spend any money they have as soon as possible, fearing that prices may rise, even if only temporarily.
Although the United States is far from this situation, central banks such as the Federal Reserve want to prevent it at all costs, so they normally intervene to attempt to curb inflation before it spirals out of control.
The issue is that the primary means of doing so is by rising interest rates, which slows the economy. If the Fed is compelled to raise interest rates too quickly, it might trigger a recession and increase unemployment, as happened in the United States in the early 1980s, when inflation was at its peak. Then-Fed head Paul Volcker was successful in bringing inflation down from a high of over 14% in 1980, but at the expense of double-digit unemployment rates.
Americans aren’t experiencing inflation anywhere near that level yet, but Jerome Powell, the Fed’s current chairman, is almost likely thinking about how to keep the country from getting there.
The Conversation has given permission to reprint this article under a Creative Commons license. Read the full article here.
Photo credit for the banner image:
Prices for used cars and trucks are up 31% year over year. David Zalubowski/AP Photo