As inflation reaches historic highs, lawmakers and analysts are debating the causes, which include pandemic-related shocks as well as government-imposed limitations and swings in consumer demand.
One New York Times writer remarked this week on Twitter that recent media headlines about inflation are “all hype.” “Policies like the $15 minimum wage” are blamed by “wealthy people.” Instead of being justified in her concern over fast rising prices for everyday items, she claims the recent coverage is “hysteria,” implying that inflation benefits lower-income people since “inflation helps borrowers, and that’s what the fuss is about…not milk prices.”
Minimum wage increases in the past have been shown to induce price increases, which disproportionately affect lower to middle-income persons who spend a bigger amount of their wages on inflation-affected commodities like groceries.
The snowball effect between minimum wage hikes, such as the $15 per hour now in place in numerous states and localities and proposed at the federal level this year, and price increases is documented in a report by Heritage Foundation fellow James Sherk. A $15 federal minimum wage, for example, represents a 107 percent increase over the current federal minimum pay of $7.25 per hour. Employers must adjust their business models to accommodate for the increased labor expenditure when governments enforce substantial minimum wage increases. In many circumstances, this necessitates firms raising consumer pricing to compensate for the higher cost of providing their goods or services. Sherk claims that this hurts minimum wage workers and lower-income consumers the most, because the costs of the products they buy have climbed as well, lowering their newly boosted salaries’ purchasing power.
According to one analysis of the existing minimum wage research, which mostly contains data on price effects from the United States, a 10% rise in the minimum wage raises prices by up to 0.3 percent.
According to one of the studies evaluated by the American Enterprise Institute, the same price boost might produce price rises of up to 2.7 percent in the southern United States, where living costs and earnings are much lower. Recent study also suggests that increased minimum wages have a greater inflationary impact on employers of minimum wage earners. A research by the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago and the United States Department of Agriculture indicated that raising the minimum wage more than doubled the price increase effect in fast-food restaurants, and much higher in lower-wage areas.
In addition, a Stanford University economist looked at the impact of price hikes by income level and discovered that while “Minimum wage workers come from a wide range of socioeconomic backgrounds, and raising the minimum wage has the greatest impact on the poorest 20% of households.
Minimum wages encourage firms to raise prices to cover some of the additional pay bill, according to this analysis of previous findings. However, this comes at a price employers must be careful not to raise prices too much, as this will generate price-sensitive client demand. Employers are unable to raise prices if they believe that doing so will reduce demand and result in decreased revenues, which will not be sufficient to fund increases in employee wages. Employers are obliged to adjust costs in other ways if this happens, such as lowering other employee benefits, reducing scheduled hours, or laying off staff entirely.
Sherk claims that the price hike effect of rising minimum wages is combined with large job loss effects, implying that minimum wage people are more likely to lose their jobs or have their hours decreased as their cost of living rises. As a result, he believes that increasing minimum wages is an unproductive approach to provide benefits to low-wage workers due to inflationary and job-killing impacts.
Does raising salaries lead to higher inflation?
Wage Increases: What Causes Inflation? Inflation is caused by wage increases because the cost of producing products and services rises as corporations pay their workers more. To compensate for the cost increase, businesses must increase the price of their goods and services in order to retain the same level of profitability.
What impact does a higher minimum wage have on the economy?
Since 2009, the federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour has remained unchanged. Increasing it would increase most low-wage employees’ earnings and family income, pulling some families out of povertybut it would also cause other low-wage workers to lose their jobs, and their family income would fall.
The Budgetary Consequences of the Raise the Wage Act of 2021 (S. 53), which CBO evaluated in The Budgetary Effects of the Raise the Wage Act of 2021, allows users to study the effects of policies that would raise the federal minimum wage. Users can also build their own policy options to see how different ways to increasing the minimum wage would influence earnings, employment, family income, and poverty.
What are the drawbacks of increasing the minimum wage?
- Despite numerous attempts to raise the minimum wage, no bill has ever passed both chambers of Congress.
- Minimum wage supporters claim that reforms are needed to help salaries keep up with rising living costs, and that a higher minimum wage will raise millions of people out of poverty.
- Opponents of raising the minimum wage claim that increased salaries will have various negative consequences, including inflation, decreased company competitiveness, and job losses.
Why is increasing the minimum wage a bad idea?
- The Biden administration wants to increase the federal minimum wage from $7.25 to $15 per hour.
- While a $15 minimum wage may benefit some employed employees, the existing data on the supply and demand side of the labor market suggests that it will price others out of the market and exacerbate the problems faced by many small firms.
- On the supply side of the labor market, Black and Hispanic workers, as well as those with lower educational attainment, are most at risk of remaining unemployed; these groups make up a significant proportion of minimum wage earners and are heavily represented in industries that have been negatively affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.
- Small businesses have been severely harmed by the pandemic on the demand side; at its worst, 41 percent of small enterprises in low-income areas closed, with a 46 percent reduction in sales since January 2020.
As part of its COVID-19 economic assistance package, the Biden administration proposes raising the federal minimum wage from $7.25 to $15 per hour. Some argue that by using the budget reconciliation procedure, Congress might raise the minimum wage with a simple majority vote in the Senate. An rise in the minimum wage, especially one as large as the one suggested, would benefit some workers while excluding others from the labor market. According to labor supply data, there are millions of unemployed employees who are low-skilled and have a low level of education. Because of the $15 minimum wage, many employees are likely to remain unemployed. On the demand side, many businesses are facing declining net revenues and, in some cases, closure; this is especially true of small enterprises already hurt by the COVID-19 crisis, which employ a disproportionate number of those individuals. A $15 minimum wage would not only stifle recovery, but it would also harm many of the employees it is supposed to aid.
The pandemic has had an impact on practically every aspect of the economy, but some industries and people have been hit particularly hard. Knowing which industries and types of workers are the most affected by the present economic environment might help determine where a significant rise in the minimum wage will cause the most harm and potentially result in more people losing their jobs.
While the Biden Administration has stated that it is committed to helping low-income individuals and families, particularly those from Black and Hispanic communities, a federally enforced minimum wage of $15 will disproportionately harm these employees. The pandemic’s destructive impact on communities of color has been extensively studied. For example, black and Latino workers make up about a quarter of the service industry workforce yet are underrepresented in management roles. Black and Hispanic workers make up 13 and 24 percent of the workforce in the leisure and hospitality business, respectively.
** Estimates for the racial groupings listed above
Because data for all races is not supplied, the terms white, black, and African American do not add up to totals. People of any race who identify as Hispanic or Latino might be Hispanic or Latino. I
Although the employment situation for Black and Hispanic employees has improved since the peak of unemployment, these groups remain disproportionately represented among the unemployed. A significant increase in the federal minimum wage could push those who are already unemployed out of the labor market, potentially resulting in more layoffs or job losses.
Those with a lower educational level are another group of workers that are particularly vulnerable. According to data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), employees who did not complete high school were disproportionately affected by the pandemic, with unemployment soaring to 21% and remaining roughly double that of 2019. Workers with a bachelor’s degree or more, on the other hand, are seeing their jobless rates rebound to 2019 levels. Workers with lower educational attainment are more likely to work at or below the minimum wage, which is unsurprising. Because up-skilling and reskilling programs are not widely available in the United States, and higher education is sometimes prohibitively expensive, workers with low educational attainment and low skills will most likely feel the effects of increasing minimum wage.
Even as the economy begins to recover, the COVID-19 pandemic has forced many firms, particularly small businesses, to close permanently or function on razor-thin margins. Many of these enterprises are already operating in a difficult climate, having had to absorb expenditures connected with increased safety precautions and state-mandated company closures while losing revenue due to decreased activity.
The expense of a $15 minimum wage might drive the most vulnerable businesses to stop hiring, reduce employee hours, eliminate positions, or close entirely.
When COVID-19 initially began to have an impact on businesses, layoffs were concentrated in industries that required in-person assistance. The leisure and hospitality business, for example, saw 40% unemployment at its height and had the highest proportion of low-wage workers, according to 2019 BLS statistics. Mining, construction, transportation, and food services are among the other businesses that have been severely impacted by the pandemic. While there has been progress, unemployment in these industries remains high.
Given the high concentrations of low-paid workers in these industries, many of whom are now unemployed, raising the minimum wage to $15 would create additional barriers to speedy reopening and rehiring, resulting in long-term unemployment for the least educated and skilled individuals.
Due to a lack of revenue and required closures, the pandemic prompted many small businesses to close temporarily; it also forced numerous enterprises to close permanently. The highest percent change in the number of open small enterprises occurred in April 2020, with a 44 percent decrease from January 2020.
The changes in the leisure and hospitality industry, which showed an almost 50% fall in open small enterprises in April 2020 compared to January 2020, are particularly noteworthy. This industry employs the vast majority of people who would be directly impacted by minimum wage hikes, many of whom are likely currently unemployed.
As previously said, closures due to reduced business and mandates resulted in income loss; while many larger businesses were able to withstand the loss, many small enterprises were forced to close permanently or resort to layoffs as a cost-cutting solution. While the Paycheck Protection Program loans, which were established as part of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, brought temporary relief to many, businesses are still struggling.
Despite an increase in revenues from April to December, the status of the leisure and hospitality business remains fragile, particularly as the number of cases continues to rise.
Given that the typical non-supervisory wage in the leisure and hospitality industry is less than the proposed $15 minimum wage, these businesses would have to manage the impact of increased costs, which would reduce net revenue even further. Many small firms would be forced to raise prices, limiting demand for goods and services, or reduce hiring, cut worker hours, or eliminate positions if the minimum wage was raised.
An rise in the federal minimum wage will worsen the economic loss already experienced by many firms and their employees. While those who are able to keep their jobs will undoubtedly profit from the raise, many others will suffer further consequences. The enormous number of unemployed people who previously worked as low-wage workers in businesses that have been hit the hardest by the pandemic are particularly vulnerable. It’s unclear whether those personnel will be required to return during this period. As firms balance reduced revenues and increasing expenditures, adding a federally required cost in the form of an increased minimum wage would result in extended unemployment, reduced work hours or hiring, and increased layoffs for low-paid workers.
https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t04.htm; https://www.bls.gov/opub/reports/minimum-wage/2019/home.htm#cps mw whe char.f.1; https://www.bls.gov/opub/reports/minimum-wage/2019/home.htm#cps mw whe_
Based on inflation, what should the minimum wage be?
Consumer prices rose 5.3 percent in August compared to the previous year, causing some anxiety as the economy recovers from the pandemic. Food prices at home increased by 3%, while food prices away from home (i.e. restaurants) increased by 4.7 percent, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ latest release this week. Rents and energy prices both increased by roughly 9%.
One point of worry for employers and employees in the United States is that activists frequently exploit inflation data to support their campaign for a $15 minimum wage, or even a higher salary of $23 per hour, despite the fact that study shows such steep rises will destroy millions of jobs.
Remember, if we kept up with inflation, the minimum wage would be $23/hr right now. $15 is a good middle ground. #RaiseTheWagehttps://t.co/44l6Rqln0F
Despite the fact that inflation has risen dramatically in the last year, the so-called “The Fight for $15” is still not based on a consumer price index. If the 2009 federal minimum wage increase to $7.25 per hour were indexed to climb with inflation, it would equal $9.22 today, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data up to August 2021.
If the minimum wage were to be adjusted to the level in 1990, it would be $7.17 now. No matter how you slice it, these data don’t even come close to, let alone support, the $23 hourly rate proposed by the union-backed One Fair Wage.
Indeed, the $15 minimum wage goal that several states and municipalities have already enacted has no precedence in history. An organizing director for the Service Employees International Union’s Fight for $15 campaign joked about the absence of genuine analysis informing their main policy goal at one meeting, saying: “We decided that $10 was too low and $20 was too much, so we settled on $15.”
Unfortunately, these draconian minimum wage targets, which lack economic justification, will wreak havoc on firms and employees as they try to recover from the pandemic. According to the impartial Congressional Budget Office, the Raise the Wage Act of 2021, which proposes a $15 minimum wage nationwide, may cost the country up to 2.7 million jobs. According to economists from Miami and Trinity Universities’ industry and state-level analyses, the hospitality and restaurant industries would bear the brunt of these effects. Increases above the $15 minimum wage would have an even bigger negative impact on employer costs, and could result in the loss of many more employment.
What if the minimum wage was raised to $15 per hour?
Legislators submitted the “Raise the Wage Act of 2021” in January 2021, with the goal of raising the federal minimum wage from $7.25 per hour to $15 per hour by 2025. It would be the first hike in more than a decade, and the longest since 1938, if passed.
Many state and local governments have already established a $15 minimum wage, while the federal minimum wage has stayed unchanged. (In 2014, for example, Seattle mandated that employers gradually raise their minimum wage until it hits $15 per hour.) Seattle’s minimum wage will be $16.69 per hour in 2021.) Nonetheless, such a huge change at the federal level will undoubtedly be controversial and hotly disputed.
Advantages
Raising the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour would help low-income people improve their overall level of life. These workers would be able to cover their monthly expenses more readily, such as rent, car payments, and other household costs. “Today, a full-time worker cannot afford a basic, two-bedroom apartment in any county in the United States,” said Representative Robert Scott, leader of the House Committee on Education and Labor. Senator Bernie Sanders has also stated that the minimum wage should be $15, as he feels that full-time workers should not be forced to live in poverty.
A second, less visible benefit of hiking the minimum wage has been proposed: improved staff morale. Not only will happier employees make for a more cohesive and effective workforce, but they may also increase customer satisfaction. Furthermore, if employees are happy with their jobs and compensation, they are less likely to leave, which saves the company money on hiring and training.
Proponents say that raising the minimum wage to $15 will assist women and minorities. A $15 minimum wage would improve the pay of 31% of African Americans and 26% of Latinos. Furthermore, a disproportionate number of minority workers live in one of the 21 states with a $7.25-per-hour minimum wage.
Disadvantages
Small firms, according to opponents of raising the minimum wage, would suffer as a result of such a significant increase. An rise in the federal minimum wage will dramatically increase small businesses’ operating costs and tighten profits, just as they are beginning to recover from the international Covid-19 outbreak.
Raising the minimum wage to $15 would also boost daycare expenditures by 21% on average in the United States. In 2019, the average hourly wage for an early childcare worker in the United States was $11.65. As a result, a nationally enforced $15 minimum wage would nearly triple the cost of labor for childcare providers.
Advocates on both sides will continue to cite several reasons in favor of their viewpoints as the federal minimum wage debate continues to elicit passionate opinions. Those who oppose a minimum wage claim that market forces should be in charge. If there is a lot of competition for talented personnel, a business may have little choice but to raise salaries to keep staff. Employers and employees should be aware of both sides of the issue and prepare for a change in the federal minimum wage law that is almost certain to occur.
(This article was greatly aided by Logan Adams, a spring clerk in our Dallas office.)
Is it good or bad to raise the minimum wage?
Democrats are sticking to their plan to raise the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour. They want to include it in the next stimulus package, but the Senate parliamentarian says it can’t be done through the budget reconciliation process. So, while it might pass in the House, it’s likely to be dropped from the Senate bill.
Now, lawmakers are proposing a “Plan B”: taxing corporations with $1 billion or more in income if they don’t pay their workers a $15 salary. Senator Josh Hawley, a Republican, proposed the bill (MO).
Some Republicans have expressed support for increasing the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour, but not to that level. Senators Mitt Romney (UT) and Tom Cotton (AR) proposed a four-year plan to raise the minimum wage to $10 per hour, but employers would have to certify that their employees are legally documented. According to a 2019 CBO assessment, raising the federal minimum wage to $10 per hour would have far fewer consequences on employees than raising it to $15 per hour, and would have no effect on the number of people living in poverty.
What makes the $15 minimum wage so bad?
Opponents of raising the minimum wage to $15 believe that it will increase labor expenses for small businesses, which account for 99 percent of all employers, resulting in layoffs, automation, or closure.
Why should the government increase the minimum wage?
Raising the federal minimum wage will boost consumer spending, boost company profits, and help the economy expand. A little increase would boost worker productivity while also lowering turnover and absenteeism. It would also help the economy as a whole by increasing consumer demand.
In 2022, how would the minimum wage be adjusted for inflation?
President Biden stated at his State of the Union address that bringing inflation under control was a primary goal, and he told businesses, “Not your wages, but your costs.” However, many firms across the country have not responded to current health or economic problems by decreasing salaries. And, in certain regions of the country, salaries are only going higher by law, as many municipal minimum wage legislation increase their rates in response to changes in the consumer price index (CPI). We present a projection of what businesses can expect during these difficult economic times, not an economic prognosis, so they can budget appropriately in the coming months and prepare for near-term (July 1) and future (January 1, 2023) necessary wage rate increases.
Running a business has been anything but simple during COVID-19. We’ve all heard about the “Great Resignation” and how it led to “wageflation” ( “According to Forbes, “a sudden, unexpected, and instantaneous surge in pay based on unique market conditions”). With the addition of inflation, some businesses may find themselves in an even more vulnerable position. Although the mid-year minimum wage increases (July 1, 2022) are still four months away, some jurisdictions have already announced their rates; the differences are notable and demonstrate the impact rising inflation can have on wages in jurisdictions that adjust their minimum wage in response to changes in the CPI.
The minimum wage in both the City of Santa Fe and the County of Santa Fe was CPI-adjusted from $12.32 to $12.95 per hour on March 1, 2022, an increase of just over 5%. The minimum wage in the District of Columbia will increase from $15.20 to $16.10 per hour on July 1, 2022, representing a nearly 6% increase. The greatest stated increase to date belongs to the City of Los Angeles, California, where the yearly adjusted minimum wage will rise from $15.00 to $16.04 per hour on July 1, 2022, a nearly 7% increase.
Factors that may impact why minimum wage CPI adjustments varies from one location to another range from the apparent to the obscure, and include, for example:
- The minimum pay rate prior to the change. The higher the existing minimum wage, the more likely there is to be a raise “Sticker Shock” is a rate that has been changed.
- The adjustment’s lookback period, as well as inflation throughout that time. There is a gap between the end of the lookback period and the start of the adjusted wage rate, but depending on how much time passes between these dates and how inflation performs in the interim, the rate bump could exceed inflation at the time the rate goes into effect or throughout the year it is in effect; of course, during the pre-adjustment period, the opposite could be true, with other items like food and consumer goods prices rising while the adjusted wage rate remains in effect; of course, during the pre-adjustment
- Whether CPI-U (Consumers) or CPI-W (Workers) is used in the adjustment (Workers). These are various inflation rates, which helps to explain why two cities with the same pre-adjustment minimum wage may have different adjusted rates.
- The adjustment’s working area. To be competitive, a smaller city can go beyond its borders and apply the CPI index to a much larger metropolis further away.
- Whether or not the law sets a limit on the annual rise. This could happen in general or by employing a different rate of inflation than the actual rate of inflation “whichever is less” standard (i.e., the rate of inflation or X percent, whichever is less).
Numerous further municipal mid-year rate adjustments will occur throughout California on July 1, 2022, so businesses should plan for a potential “wagequake” across the state. However, tremors may not be limited to the West Coast, as municipal minimum wage rates in the Midwest (Illinois) and the Mid-Atlantic (Maryland) will also alter. While concerns about near-term wage changes are primarily local, firms across the country should prepare for the potential that inflation does not moderate sufficiently through 2022, resulting in state-level rate increases on January 1, 2023. (or December 31, 2022, in New York). This could effect both exempt and non-exempt employees if it happens. States frequently add a multiplier to the minimum wage to determine the minimum salary required for the executive, administrative, or professional exemption to apply; a state-law inside sales exemption could face a similar minimum wage multiplication scenario. In addition, the state may annually increase the exemption’s minimum hourly rate for specified hourly professionals (or medical in California).
Although we don’t have a crystal ball to look into the future, we may forecast that things will become more difficult, just like wage and hour regulations.